Nah, I wouldn't be, 'cause this is the Madden forum
Anyway it's all just pure speculation if people would bash on 2k or not. All I can say it that I still prefer 2k8 despite its flaws to all the current-gen Madden games, because the fundamental gameplay is solid. If Madden starts dishing up with fundamentally sound gameplay I'd be extremely pleased and would be a lot more patient with EA.