nope, andrew luck went 3rd overall and was a 86 with A potential, cam newton was a 1 rounder and was a 71 with B potential. The key is to save it before you load your draft class. Once it's loaded, madden randomly determines their potential and their draft stock. So my advice is to keep randomizing until you find a good qb stock class. For example, mines went Andrew luck (1 round), Jake Locker (1-2 round), Cam Newton (1-2 round), and the rest. It can be a pain to keep doing it over and over again, but in the end it pays off.