[maademperor]

Quote: Originally Posted by carnalnirvana

that vid on youtube is a classic example of i'll trust my eyes not being a good idea. all madden makes any player for the cpu 99+ in almost all of his relevant to position ratings while it makes the user about 20( i really mean a rating of 20.......)j/k so that punter playing LT is a 99 on all amdden in every OL rating he has a 99 even though it says 12 yes this is horrible rating logic........ but it is what it is...... now does weight and height matter NO they dont in terms of reality. wieght seems to me modified by the strength rating. if a guy has a 30 STR he wont truck or push anyone while if i give a 160lb guy 99 he would throw off 5 guys this is the same in many other sport games, ex nba 2k11 on HOF shaq cant back down nash, the problem with madden is the STR rating isnt curved tight enough this year, there is little difference between a 55 STR and a 85. this is why devs can say their engine is capable of prodicing 2k esque gameplay, i believe them but i know they would never rate the game approiately to produce it and the curves they use dont deliver it either this argument is deeper than madden is bad and broken? with the right tools and editing especially on the PC( where we have the tools) you can see where the problems are........

I think you got the video backwards...I'm pretty sure that by putting the player skill level at all madden he was showing how even a super buffed CPU player (in this case Suh) couldnt beat his paltry created center. The author of the video was playing offense so the odds should have been in the cpu's favor to win the matchup (off of the poor rating of his center and his center being even further skewed by being bound by all madden skill level).