Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find?

[BlueNGold]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

Player tendencies are really a big deal for me. That alone get me closer to buying the game then anything else has in the last 3 years.

Same here. I'm hoping the tendencies have as big an effect as they should because it'll be great to finally see differences between every player on the field. The closest they ever came to that was the Weapons feature, which was a massive fail.

It took EA awhile, but it looks like, between this and Fight Night, they're finally starting to realize that editable player tendencies are a huge thing with sports games.

[roadman]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

I may have went over board a little bit with the gimmick thing. All I am asking is stop trying to "sell" me a game with new features....improve the current features and make me want to buy it. I hope that makes sense. Honestly I would cut the Ultimate Team feature and improved on the basic franchise (online and offline). for some reason and maybe it was just me Ultimate Team just rubbed me the wrong way. Sorry folks ain't trying to be negative. I will go back to moderating instead of commenting.

Nah, mods have opinions and voices too.

I just don't care about MUT so, I don't let it bother me. I know it's a money maker for them, so, I just let it be. Otherwise, I thought it was good stuff for a teaser.

[roadman]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

Agree.. This guy hit it on the nail.. I'm surprised that some are satisfied at what they just saw... It's the same thing every every year.. It's almost like they have to throw in some gimmicks for the lack of serious improvement in gameplay.. imo this teaser video was a good way to hide the same actual gameplay while trying to hype people with a few new features and gimmicks. Thats great, but I think this poster above said it best, "start with the making the perfect game on the field before you start adding things like this." Exactly.. I guess thats what baffles me the most is how can the Dev's continue adding things like gimmicks every year instead of focusing on whats most important, and thats making the game play feal right and realistic?? I don't get it..

And yeah we can say well at least they are headed in the right direction, well thats fine but my concern is how long its taking to get where they are headed.. So far they have been headed in the right direction for 6+ years now.. Whats sad is that NCAA is truley looking like they finally are getting there and they have always been behind Madden.. whats wrong with that picture?? wow.

I'm just curious, what did you find gimmicky about the teaser video besides MUT? Custom Play Books, TV Style Presentation, the 3d grass like NCAA has? A lot of people have been clamoring for Custom Playbooks and TV Style Presentation for awhile, including myself.

[SageInfinite]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

If 1 of the new features is TV-style presentation, I hope its actual TV style presentation, and not what EA/Tiburon thinks is TV-style presentation. Which is what we have always gotten.

[gmen92]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

I'm just curious, what did you find gimmicky about the teaser video besides MUT? Custom Play Books, TV Style Presentation, the 3d grass like NCAA has? A lot of people have been clamoring for Custom Playbooks and TV Style Presentation for awhile, including myself.

What did you find that was different as far as gameplay from madden 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, etc.. ?? As for me, I did mention "features" and gimmicks.. I just threw in gimmicks because thats usually what is added every year to Madden. The Bottom line is instead of them adding things why don't they just focus on fixing the real issue and thats gameplay?? That was my main concern, not so much features and gimmicks.. It's like Adambroski said, "it's going to take some time".. Well it's going to continue taking time if they continue add things and not focus on fixing the core gameplay.. idk, why is it so hard to understand??

[BlueNGold]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

What did you find that was different as far as gameplay from madden 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, etc.. ?? As for me, I did mention "features" and gimmicks.. I just threw in gimmicks because thats usually what is added every year to Madden. The Bottom line is instead of them adding things why don't they just focus on fixing the real issue and thats gameplay?? That was my main concern, not so much features and gimmicks.. It's like Adambroski said, "it's going to take some time".. Well it's going to continue taking time if they continue added things and not focus on fixing the core gameplay.. idk, why is it so hard to understand??

Why is it so hard to understand that there wasn't nearly enough actual gameplay shown in a TEASER to make that judgment?

[PSRusse83]

If 1 of the new features is TV-style presentation, I hope its actual TV style presentation, and not what EA/Tiburon thinks is TV-style presentation. Which is what we have always gotten.

HAHA that is hilarious. I agree Im not really into what Ea sports thinks is a football broadcast. Those replays in M11 were awesome but Ncaa looked awful.

[Pacman83]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

What did you find that was different as far as gameplay from madden 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, etc.. ?? As for me, I did mention "features" and gimmicks.. I just threw in gimmicks because thats usually what is added every year to Madden. The Bottom line is instead of them adding things why don't they just focus on fixing the real issue and thats gameplay?? That was my main concern, not so much features and gimmicks.. It's like Adambroski said, "it's going to take some time".. Well it's going to continue taking time if they continue added things and not focus on fixing the core gameplay.. idk, why is it so hard to understand??

It's a teaser to show some areas of focus this year...there is other info out there if you look...

http://www.osatwork.com/forums/showthread.php?t=474423

Seriously man...whats is there to complain about this early in the year? (When it comes to M12?) Most of this info seems like what we've been asking for...and not much has been confirmed yet...and all this focuses on the gameplay...so idk

[shyvoodoo]

Please EA can we have injuries in CPU vs. CPU games!!!
The video got me intrigue and excited by the way....

ben
voodoo

[rogueleader]

I looked and the thing that pops up or at least the only thing i see is Gameplanning and its attached to the Tease below. But I of course hope youre right. Whatever has been stopping Madden from looking good is beyond me.

Here's what I'm talking about, it happens just before the custom playbook video comes up:

http://img121.imageshack.us/i/maddenteaser.png/

[WDOgF0reL1fe]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

I love that last year, all they focused on was gameplay and people were like
"OMGZORS WE WANT FEATURES AND WHAT ABOUT FRANCHISE MODE!!!????"

Now, they say they are doing more features, enhancements to modes, and redesigning franchise mode and now of course its all
"THey need to focus ONLY ON GAMEPLAY. WHat is wrong with them?!"

I cant wait for Madden.
Im not even a franchise guy, but I just like what I saw with the foot planting and supposed 3d grass.

[gmen92]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

Why is it so hard to understand that there wasn't nearly enough actual gameplay shown in a TEASER to make that judgment?

If i had a nickle for every time someone said that, i would be rich! Come on now seriously? It's Madden we are talking about.. Its the same gameplay every year regardless of what they show...

[guaps]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

I love that last year, all they focused on was gameplay and people were like
"OMGZORS WE WANT FEATURES AND WHAT ABOUT FRANCHISE MODE!!!????"

Now, they say they are doing more features, enhancements to modes, and redesigning franchise mode and now of course its all
"THey need to focus ONLY ON GAMEPLAY. WHat is wrong with them?!"

I cant wait for Madden.
Im not even a franchise guy, but I just like what I saw with the foot planting and supposed 3d grass.

I'm in the gameplay camp. No amount of presentation, player tendencies etc. will make any difference if they don't address gameplay. I'm mean why would you want any RB to run out of bounce with the current state of gameplay? You'll most likely get a forward falling animation if you run into defenders. The reason why player tendencies works so well in, say, FIFA 11 is because they've implemented it on top of really solid gameplay.

And last year they didn't focus solely on gameplay. The biggest marketing gimmick last year was GameFlow/GamePlanning. And while they might have addressed Run Blocking AI, it was back to status quo as soon as the blocking reached the second level. And sideline catches wasn't a new gameplay feature, it was just the first year it seemed to work. Etc. Etc.

From the teaser (the two field goal attempts) the OL/DL interaction looks exactly the same as previous years. People morph into 1-on-1 animations (in the second video - on the left side - you can clearly see a player being morphed several feet into a defender) and a single player is left untouched, so he can attempt to block the field goal. Additionally, if you look at the surprise onside kick, it looks like the diving animation is motion shifting the defender out of the way, showing absolutely no respect for momentum.

The only thing I'm left "reassured" of after watching the teaser is that Tiburon probably won't be addressing major gameplay concerns - otherwise they would have shown some tackles and/or proper OL/DL interactions in the teaser.

[cgalligan]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

I wonder if custom playbooks will work for online franchise?

I'm torn on weather or not I want them to...

On one hand, it would be cool to bring your favorite plays and formations online and compete vs others in your online chise.

On the other hand, I don't feel like defending the same 5 or 6 money plays from the different playbooks all game long...

[RedZoneD25]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Video - First Look Reveals Custom Playbooks, What Else Can You Find

I wonder if custom playbooks will work for online franchise?

I'm torn on weather or not I want them to...

On one hand, it would be cool to bring your favorite plays and formations online and compete vs others in your online chise.

On the other hand, I don't feel like defending the same 5 or 6 money plays from the different playbooks all game long...

That's the only iffy part to me. I'm not much of an online gamer, but if by chance they do allow them online, I'm lucky enough to know a bunch of sim gamers. Hopefully you do as well.