I've been updating 2k5 rosters since... 2004
I still play that game religiously. I love it.
I thought Madden 08 on the PC was the best Madden I played - even though it was missing some stuff, the game play was incredibly smooth. But, it was still Madden and still was lacking things 2K5 had.
I just don't understand why Madden can't equal or surpass 2K5 level on a next-gen system.