There is no doubt in my mind that a full physics/collision system is on the way. Taking a lil minute to get here, lol but I'm sure its coming. Mean time in between time, when it comes to Madden/NCAA you can take it or leave it. I've always taken it, was disappointed with 06-09, but greatly enjoyed 10 and 11.
I agree that full physics/collision probably wont be in 12 but we're getting there.