IMHO, no. I, personally, have been burned too often. These features in NCAA and Madden sound great, and the articles and videos add to their allure. However, every year we seem to get excited about a new feature, and once people unwrap the games and play them, the games fail to live up to the hype.
That said, there are always people who feed the negativity. I mean, we see it in this thread already. People have just found out that we have the capability to begin our dynasties as coordinators. It's a brand new feature, and yet even on the first page of this thread people are expecting more. In that sense, EA - or most game developers - cannot win for losing.
Four or five years ago, I might've already placed my order for each game. But more responsibilities at home, restricted funds and poor product development in the past mean I'm going to wait and see reviews and rent them before I commit to them.
That's just my 2 cents.

Comment