YOu have one of the best teams of all time so it might be that you might not have the best competition. You may want to try using a current team.
Are you playing an Association with the 96 Bulls? If so maybe do one with a bunch of other classic teams (replacing their modern day counterpart) to spice up the competition.
YOu can always tweak the shot success sliders for yourself as well as tune down the dunk success. I have to imagine your just slaying teams in the paint with Jordan.