OS at E3: NCAA Football 12 Preview

[The JareBear]

Re: OS at E3: NCAA Football 12 Preview

One of the few things I really agree with Ben H. about is the special teams balance. Imagine, if they make it possible to block punts how easily could that tactic be exploited by "savvy" gamers and used online to block it almost every time?

When Ben said something like, "you have to be careful not to make it too easy to block kicks" I agreed whole heartedly, I would rather have no blocks than too many to be honest.

[Hova57]

Re: OS at E3: NCAA Football 12 Preview

One of the few things I really agree with Ben H. about is the special teams balance. Imagine, if they make it possible to block punts how easily could that tactic be exploited by "savvy" gamers and used online to block it almost every time?

When Ben said something like, "you have to be careful not to make it too easy to block kicks" I agreed whole heartedly, I would rather have no blocks than too many to be honest.

I disagree with that cause there are teams in college that are special team gurus see Virginia Tech. You should be allowed to block kicks not every kick but at least come close . If I'm playing a FCS team I should be able to block two or three punts or two or three fg. See ricky sapp he lead college fb in block fgs his senior year. they are holding back the excitement of special teams leaving the kicker and returner to score.

[Schreck]

Re: OS at E3: NCAA Football 12 Preview

I disagree with that cause there are teams in college that are special team gurus see Virginia Tech. You should be allowed to block kicks not every kick but at least come close . If I'm playing a FCS team I should be able to block two or three punts or two or three fg. See ricky sapp he lead college fb in block fgs his senior year. they are holding back the excitement of special teams leaving the kicker and returner to score.

Yes there are teams that are really good at getting after the kicker, but they are pretty few and far between. Last year there were 273 blocked punts/field goals in college football, or about 2.275 per the 120 teams over 12/13 games. 73 teams got all of those, so almost 50 teams had no blocked kicks. So yeah blocked kicks happen, and it would be great if they were more accurate in the game, but it would get really old if guys figured out how to block a kick or more every game.

[The JareBear]

Re: OS at E3: NCAA Football 12 Preview

First of all, you are absolutely right about special teams, they are a big part of the game in real life and shouldn't be overlooked. I am well aware of Frank Beamer's influence on his special teams program and the success they have year in and year out.

I guess what I was trying to say is that, in a game where even the most realistic aspects can be exploited unfairly, it probably is more difficult than we think to program a fair way to block kicks once in a while and not be able to do it every single time

You're right though, it isn't very exciting when you know the kick will never be blocked....

How many blocked kicks does the best team in that category have in a season typically? 9?

[coogrfan]

Re: OS at E3: NCAA Football 12 Preview

Yes there are teams that are really good at getting after the kicker, but they are pretty few and far between. Last year there were 273 blocked punts/field goals in college football, or about 2.275 per the 120 teams over 12/13 games. 73 teams got all of those, so almost 50 teams had no blocked kicks. So yeah blocked kicks happen, and it would be great if they were more accurate in the game, but it would get really old if guys figured out how to block a kick or more every game.

True story-back in the PS1 days I had a Madden buddy who figured out that if he lined up in a certain goal line D he could literally make it impossible for the other guy to kick fg's. It didn't matter if was a 60 yarder or an extra point, nor did it matter how fast you tried to get the kick away -- if you tried it it was getting blocked. Used to drive me absolutely nuts.

For that reason I am firmly in the "too few blocks is better than too many" camp.

[JaySmooov]

True story-back in the PS1 days I had a Madden buddy who figured out that if he lined up in a certain goal line D he could literally make it impossible for the other guy to kick fg's. It didn't matter if was a 60 yarder or an extra point, nor did it matter how fast you tried to get the kick away -- if you tried it it was getting blocked. Used to drive me absolutely nuts.

For that reason I am firmly in the "too few blocks is better than too many" camp.

Exactly. It would end up dong more harm than good, and that's what needs to be considered every year when adding something.

Also if anyone is looking for some NCAA 12 gameplay, check the facebook page. There's "RAW" gameplay of Ohio State vs Nebraska in a night game

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qTgRQ6bbEBQ