I have to say the same; Not just for NFL 2k5, but for Madden 07 last gen as well (first madden I bought, bare w/ me). Both of those games feel and play better IMO. As for graphics, lets give credit where credit is due, Madden 12 is very easy on the eyes. But, on the same token, when the game looks as good as it does, I feel cheated when I press the play button.