wow, call reversed

[krong1170]

So I'm playing Fresno St. as SJ State(trying to build my way up to a good job) and I'm in the red zone an throw it to my wr in the endzonebut no td because my guy was out of bounds. Play gets challenged and reversed giving me the td, just one problem though...........my guy didn't catch the ball and they still called it a td. wtf???

[Siggy778]

Re: wow, call reversed

What's annoying is that I've never seen a booth review NOT getting reversed. Not realistic at all.

[bulls23]

Re: wow, call reversed

Working well for me:

Had a 40 yd pass to the sideline ruled a catch by the referees, didn't look like to me he even got one foot in. Challenged it and the replay showed one foot completely out of bounds and the toe of the other foot touching the line. Overturned.

I've only had one challengeable play and I won it.

[CUTigers89]

Re: wow, call reversed

I've had two plays overturned, but i've also had a few plays where the call was clearly wrong and was upheld

[Charleston_Tiger]

Re: wow, call reversed

Well I had a play reviewed in RTG mode...... when I was in HIGH SCHOOL!!!

[Broncos86]

Re: wow, call reversed

Yeah, I had a WR come down with the ball and his first foot was well out of bounds in the endzone. Called no touchdown. Refs then reversed it and called it a TD.

[calbears7]

Re: wow, call reversed

I dont like the fact that you cant challenge if a ball carrier crossed the plane or not

[brettmickey]

Re: wow, call reversed

I've had 3 bad calls in 1 game against Michigan (the 3rd bad call made me lose). The first one was a "fumble" when my player clearly was down. Challenged, overturned. The next was a long pass down the sideline they called a "catch". Challenged, overturned. Now I have no more challenges left. Final drive of the game I'm down by 2 and I'm in field goal range so I keep the ball on the ground and run the clock out. I run an inside carry and once again my player "fumbles" when he is clearly on the ground but I have no challenges left and they recover and it's game over. Completely screwed over by the refs.
I don't mind them getting a call wrong here or there (2 times MAX in one game) but that was just ridiculous...

[bulls23]

Re: wow, call reversed

Yeah, I had a WR come down with the ball and his first foot was well out of bounds in the endzone. Called no touchdown. Refs then reversed it and called it a TD.

Was this the desired result for you?

Reminder to everyone, college rules you only need one foot in.

[Equinox831]

Re: wow, call reversed

Well I had a play reviewed in RTG mode...... when I was in HIGH SCHOOL!!!

Well it's a mechanic in the game. I don't really think that's a game breaker either...

[Sammidysam]

Re: wow, call reversed

Well it's a mechanic in the game. I don't really think that's a game breaker either...

Yeah but they should just keep the bad call since it's high school.

[mercalnd]

Re: wow, call reversed

Reminder to everyone, college rules you only need one foot in.

True. But it has to be the first foot to touch the ground.

[ACardAttack]

Re: wow, call reversed

What's annoying is that I've never seen a booth review NOT getting reversed. Not realistic at all.

I have seen one not get reversed a couple games ago...im 2/3 on getting reversed....I should be 3/3...but since my qb isnt tom brady, they called a fumble when clearly his arm was moving forward with the ball and didnt overturn it

[gohogsfan14]

Re: wow, call reversed

I've had 3 bad calls in 1 game against Michigan (the 3rd bad call made me lose). The first one was a "fumble" when my player clearly was down. Challenged, overturned. The next was a long pass down the sideline they called a "catch". Challenged, overturned. Now I have no more challenges left. Final drive of the game I'm down by 2 and I'm in field goal range so I keep the ball on the ground and run the clock out. I run an inside carry and once again my player "fumbles" when he is clearly on the ground but I have no challenges left and they recover and it's game over. Completely screwed over by the refs.
I don't mind them getting a call wrong here or there (2 times MAX in one game) but that was just ridiculous...

Must have been SEC refs

[Ziza9Noles94]

Re: wow, call reversed

I've had 3 bad calls in 1 game against Michigan (the 3rd bad call made me lose). The first one was a "fumble" when my player clearly was down. Challenged, overturned. The next was a long pass down the sideline they called a "catch". Challenged, overturned. Now I have no more challenges left. Final drive of the game I'm down by 2 and I'm in field goal range so I keep the ball on the ground and run the clock out. I run an inside carry and once again my player "fumbles" when he is clearly on the ground but I have no challenges left and they recover and it's game over. Completely screwed over by the refs.
I don't mind them getting a call wrong here or there (2 times MAX in one game) but that was just ridiculous...

Ah, you have to remember to turn off Ron Cherry Mode before starting your games. Should eliminate that issue.