[wheelman990]

I have to agree, how does Peyton Manning not get a 99? Because he didnt carry the entire team to the super bowl again? Give me a break. First thing I do is bump Manning to 99 and Brady to 97. Rogers is fine at 98, and Rivers gets 95, Brees 94, and the rest are 90 and down IMO.

I realize Manning is only 1 point away from 99, I just cant believe Manning is less then Brady. I don't see it at all. Brady is not any more consistent even in the playoffs IMO. The Patriots team though was much much more consistent though. If Manning wants a super bowl he has to put up 35+points every playoff and super bowl game to win. People need to stop ranking qb's as team accomplishments IMO