NCAA Football 12 Roster Glitch Confirmed, Patch to Address Concerns

[MattUM2]

Re: Possible roster glitch

I did a dynasty sim. It looks like no quarterbacks rush at all.

[LionsFanNJ]

Re: Possible roster glitch

The bigger problem is that it just isn't QBs, it is random positions on every team that is changed, ALONG WITH THE QB.

So therefore we have to comb through every position just to make sure they are on the correct tendancy, if not we have to greatly alter ratings to put them on the correct tendancy.

Not only is that time consuming, but you will have some people too weak and some people too strong.

Since different people change to their correct tendancy with different ratings. Some have to be too high, some too low.

See what I mean ?

I know what you're saying. I found Balanced and Speed HB's are swapped as well after naming after doing a quick ALL team roster sort and running down the list.

[Cpterp22]

Re: Possible roster glitch

Sad part is we finally got QB's that take off and the whole game might be messed up because of it

[Redacted01]

Re: Possible roster glitch

If you make a player from scratch with Denards exact ratings, what does his tendency turn out to be then?? Is his ratings truely a balanced player???

95 speed
99 accel

90 THP
83 THA

Leans towards scrambler, but still close to looking balanced. Im just curious if a player is created exactly like denard from scratch is he balanced or a scrambler.

I'm curious as well, although in the edit menu, it still says Denard is a scrambler, which is what he was on the base roster. I doubt you guys changed his ratings.

[LionsFanNJ]

Re: Possible roster glitch

give me ten minutes. I'm gonna make one from scratch in the non named roster.

EDIT: Same issue. Scrambler tendency on the edit ratings screen, back on the main screen hes Balanced.

[bgdave39]

Re: Possible roster glitch

It seems pretty clear what the issue is to me. EA's has player tendencies assigned based off certain ratings yet assigned certain tendencies in creating the rosters as "overrides" to the default tendency determining system. IE, when the rosters are edited and saved, it reverts back to the ratings based system of determining styles.

Here's hoping to an easy Tuner based fix.

[Roggie]

Re: Possible roster glitch

This one may be the final straw for me. This is definitely reaching NASCAR 2011 territory.

[MattUM2]

Re: Possible roster glitch

Wait till news of this spreads and guys find out theyre wasting time making edits, theyll burn this B down.

This is massive black eye for EA, even if it is fixed, this hurts, a lot. Can anyone play a option team and see if they try anything wonky? Just out of curiosity.

Yup as a editor. I just found out about this. I have one member testing my rosters. I did a dynasty sim and it looks like no QB are rushing at all.

The other positions being a problem have made me stop. I will still create my excel files in hopes that something can be fixed. If so I can plug everything in. But the past week has been a waste, plugging in information, editing hometowns, body builds, equipment.

All QB's have been edited to an exact science to play to the abilty the show on tv every saturday. But now it's doesn't look to be that way.

This needs to be fixed quick.

[Roggie]

Re: Possible roster glitch

It seems pretty clear what the issue is to me. EA's has player tendencies assigned based off certain ratings yet assigned certain tendencies in creating the rosters as "overrides" to the default tendency determining system. IE, when the rosters are edited and saved, it reverts back to the ratings based system of determining styles.

Here's hoping to an easy Tuner based fix.

This doesn't seem right at all. Players who have no business becoming scramblers are scrambling. Andrew Luck is not close to a scrambler. It's every single balanced and scrambling QB switched, not a choice few. And other positions as well.

[drlw322]

Re: Possible roster glitch

How many times did he put someone on their *** with his new found strength?

None actually, he got stuffed twice on the option keeper. He had a 7 yard run off a pass play that he slide on and a other option keeper for like 14 yards and slide on again

I think trucking and tackle break has more to do with it. I don't think the strength effects that much.

[Redacted01]

Re: Possible roster glitch

It seems pretty clear what the issue is to me. EA's has player tendencies assigned based off certain ratings yet assigned certain tendencies in creating the rosters as "overrides" to the default tendency determining system. IE, when the rosters are edited and saved, it reverts back to the ratings based system of determining styles.

Here's hoping to an easy Tuner based fix.

That's not it, otherwise, if I changed Denard Robinson even one point, he would become balanced in the edit menu; he is a scramber in the edit menu. There is a lost connection between the edit menu calculating him as a scrambler and the roster menu saying he is balanced. The opposite for balanced QB's. Same with power and balanced backs, etc... Something is lost in translation; it is not an override.

[buckeye02]

Re: Possible roster glitch

This one may be the final straw for me. This is definitely reaching NASCAR 2011 territory.

LMAO, or entering Madden 08 territory

[fincane]

Re: Possible roster glitch

Playing Georgia Tech vs Oregon as I type. Switching back and forth between teams. I'm just playing defense. "Fixing" the QBs to make them actual scramblers has made the option on both sides much more effective. Good decisions by GT QB. Actually turning up field for yards as opposed to pitching when he has plenty of room to run. Whole different game.

[buckeye02]

Re: Possible roster glitch

Yup as a editor. I just found out about this. I have one member testing my rosters. I did a dynasty sim and it looks like no QB are rushing at all.

The other positions being a problem have made me stop. I will still create my excel files in hopes that something can be fixed. If so I can plug everything in. But the past week has been a waste, plugging in information, editing hometowns, body builds, equipment.

All QB's have been edited to an exact science to play to the abilty the show on tv every saturday. But now it's doesn't look to be that way.

This needs to be fixed quick.

Yeah we are putting a hold on our roster edits until something is said by EA.

Strength shouldnt factor in breaking tackles or trucking technically. If breaking tackles was determined by strength, then why is there a need for a BTK or TRK rating???

EA has more detailed ratings than they can handle.

Remember the big release day feature. Adjusting ratings in dynasty, did this cause the screw up???

Someone should delete their game data and not download the patch, try it then. Doubt it changes anything, just curious. It sucks that editing future recruits will cause this problem as well.

[Redacted01]

Re: Possible roster glitch

I'll do Oregon vs. Army and something like Nebraska and Georgia Tech this afternoon. One with names and one without. Spread vs. option. I hope to be amazed at the difference... and then sadly disappointed.