NCAA Football 12 Roster Glitch Confirmed, Patch to Address Concerns

[aarontab]

Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

Your sentences and thoughts are convoluted.

I know what you're getting at, but BUG is different than "we didn't realize that just editing names would remove our roster tweaks".

How is that not a BUG!? I go and edit someone's shoes and his player tendency complete reverses! Not to mention, it's obvious now that a player tendency is KEY to the way a player acts on the field.

That's a BUG!

Take it easy, semantics aside, i was agreeing with you. I didn't program the game, just offering a possible explanation that at least makes 50% sense....

[Gotmadskillzson]

Re: Possible roster glitch

Quick question..

if a DE is pass rusher or Run stopper is decided by their Ratings, not the "tendency in their roster".
If a OL is Pass blocker or Run Blocker is decided by their RB ratings and not by a label.

Why this is changing then? it should be a "cosmetically" thing.

I think it has to do with the new coding Madden 12 has this year. Truth be told Madden and NCAA share the same engine and coding.

This year Madden 12 has player tendancies. Therefore tendancies have to matter. With that said, that is why in NCAA 12, what ever the tendancy says on the main screen, that is how that player is going to play.

[BaylorBearBryant]

Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

Take it easy, semantics aside, i was agreeing with you. I didn't program the game, just offering a possible explanation that at least makes 50% sense....

Sorry, I didn't mean to come off as harsh. I'm just pretty upset about this whole situation.

I think it has to do with the new coding Madden 12 has this year. Truth be told Madden and NCAA share the same engine and coding.

This year Madden 12 has player tendancies. Therefore tendancies have to matter. With that said, that is why in NCAA 12, what ever the tendancy says on the main screen, that is how that player is going to play.

You could be right. That's a very real possibility.

[drlw322]

Re: Possible roster glitch

I think it has to do with the new coding Madden 12 has this year. Truth be told Madden and NCAA share the same engine and coding.

This year Madden 12 has player tendancies. Therefore tendancies have to matter. With that said, that is why in NCAA 12, what ever the tendancy says on the main screen, that is how that player is going to play.

good assessment, I have to agree i think that's the problem

[northface28]

Re: Possible roster glitch

I think it has to do with the new coding Madden 12 has this year. Truth be told Madden and NCAA share the same engine and coding.

This year Madden 12 has player tendancies. Therefore tendancies have to matter. With that said, that is why in NCAA 12, what ever the tendancy says on the main screen, that is how that player is going to play.

Furthermore, is this issue in Madden should you edit someone? God, this is ugly.

[ActLikeYouCrow]

Re: Possible roster glitch

Quick question..

if a DE is pass rusher or Run stopper is decided by their Ratings, not the "tendency in their roster".
If a OL is Pass blocker or Run Blocker is decided by their RB ratings and not by a label.

Why this is changing then? it should be a "cosmetically" thing.

in theory youre right, but the tendency label overrides the ratings based on what everyone is seeing.

The reason this is happening is because BY RATING they must be scramblers but EA must manually edit the tendencies to match their real life tendencies. That way they can have a guy who is fast BUT is not going to scramble as much and will still use his arm. Editing makes the player revert back to what his actual ratings dictate. DONE AND DONE.

im not sure this is the case because why would it stay the same in the edit screen and why when i edit a balanced qb on teambuilder and give him denard robinson's ratings would he become a scrambler. its a bug.

[Gotmadskillzson]

Re: Possible roster glitch

Furthermore, is this issue in Madden should you edit someone? God, this is ugly.

Well I am sure now that they know it is a problem in NCAA 12 and they share the same code, they going to be testing it out in Madden 12. And if it is a problem in Madden 12 too, they probably will just do a release day patch for that game.

[aarontab]

Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

I'm actually kind of surprised this is the first gamekiller this year, i'm surprised it wasn't something in dynasty mode. Lost that prop bet.

This means:
a) Named rosters as they are now are unusable
b) Dynasties that have been started will have to be restarted (RTG and OD too)
c) Ratings (possibly) don't tie into tendencies as much as would be hoped for, which if that's true, the new recruits are based solely on ratings and don't get the benefit of having somebody tweak tendencies
d) EA couldn't find menstruation on white panties.

[BaylorBearBryant]

Re: Possible roster glitch

in theory youre right, but the tendency label overrides the ratings based on what everyone is seeing.

Yes the tendency label seems to trump all. For Denard's scrambling ratings to be implemented correctly, he first has to be listed as a "scrambler."

[aarontab]

Re: Possible roster glitch

im not sure this is the case because why would it stay the same in the edit screen and why when i edit a balanced qb on teambuilder and give him denard robinson's ratings would he become a scrambler. its a bug.

Then yes, it appears it's a bug.

[northface28]

Re: Possible roster glitch

Well I am sure now that they know it is a problem in NCAA 12 and they share the same code, they going to be testing it out in Madden 12. And if it is a problem in Madden 12 too, they probably will just do a release day patch for that game.

Testing? No. Get outta here.

[Redacted01]

Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

I have been working so I missed a page here now, but to the person saying change the sliders... why? The game played fine with my sliders and no names, but Elway invented a time machine and changed his name to Andrew Luck with names. It's a bug. I see some other people came around. If you guys want some checking done, PM me some things if they aren't able to get on and I'll have an excuse not to work on this haha.

[northface28]

Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

I'm actually kind of surprised this is the first gamekiller this year, i'm surprised it wasn't something in dynasty mode. Lost that prop bet.

This means:
a) Named rosters as they are now are unusable
b) Dynasties that have been started will have to be restarted (RTG and OD too)
c) Ratings (possibly) don't tie into tendencies as much as would be hoped for, which if that's true, the new recruits are based solely on ratings and don't get the benefit of having somebody tweak tendencies
d) EA couldn't find menstruation on white panties.

Falls out of chair laughing @ D.

[Hunkerdown]

Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

I'm actually kind of surprised this is the first gamekiller this year, i'm surprised it wasn't something in dynasty mode. Lost that prop bet.

This means:
a) Named rosters as they are now are unusable
b) Dynasties that have been started will have to be restarted (RTG and OD too)
c) Ratings (possibly) don't tie into tendencies as much as would be hoped for, which if that's true, the new recruits are based solely on ratings and don't get the benefit of having somebody tweak tendencies
d) EA couldn't find menstruation on white panties.

This is some serios s***, just ruined experience for me, and I have to restart OD and offline dynasties????? wtf EA. So all we can use is default rosters with fake names.

[RIP GUTT CAPONE]

Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

Yea, that was the funniest thing i heard all week,