NCAA Football 12 Roster Glitch Confirmed, Patch to Address Concerns

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jenglund
    Rookie
    • Apr 2004
    • 229

    #421
    Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

    Originally posted by Bumble14
    No disrespect, but how is this a gamebreaker? I understand it messes around with the realism of certain players, but the game is not unplayable due to this issue--nothing is physically happening that is making the game unplayable like in NCAA Basketball 10. There are thousands of people out there who don't even care that this bug exists and are enjoying this game.

    Also--the game plays without these issues minus the named rosters. If you are that bothered by the gameplay with the named rosters, delete them and play with the numbered rosters until the patch hits. Remember back in the PS1 days?

    Major oversight by EA? Possibly. Major inconvenience for us that want to start dynasty's? Yes. Gamebreaker? No.

    We just are stuck waiting for the patch--yes it sucks. End of story.
    Autonaming rosters didn't change the tendencies for me last night. Actually, I just checked Denard Robinson...autonamed him and he remained a Scrambler. So, I'm pretty sure you could use fake names and not just numbers if you were so inclined.
    Playing:
    NBA 2K23 on PS5, Red Dead Redemption II, World of Outlaws, MLB The Show 22

    Comment

    • crabcola
      Rookie
      • Jul 2008
      • 185

      #422
      Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

      Originally posted by Bumble14
      No disrespect, but how is this a gamebreaker? I understand it messes around with the realism of certain players, but the game is not unplayable due to this issue--nothing is physically happening that is making the game unplayable like in NCAA Basketball 10. There are thousands of people out there who don't even care that this bug exists and are enjoying this game.

      Also--the game plays without these issues minus the named rosters. If you are that bothered by the gameplay with the named rosters, delete them and play with the numbered rosters until the patch hits. Remember back in the PS1 days?


      Major oversight by EA? Possibly. Major inconvenience for us that want to start dynasty's? Yes. Gamebreaker? No.

      We just are stuck waiting for the patch--yes it sucks. End of story.

      No offense, Bumble, when is the last time we weren't waiting on a patch for NCAA Football because of a major oversight like this one? It is something HUGE every year. It is just usually something different each time. And yes, for those who are interested more in the dynasty aspect of the game, this one is a BIG, BIG, oversight.
      Most people don't know what it means to be champion... Oklahoma invented it. ~Barry Switzer

      Comment

      • northface28
        Pro
        • Jul 2009
        • 762

        #423
        Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

        Originally posted by Bumble14
        No disrespect, but how is this a gamebreaker? I understand it messes around with the realism of certain players, but the game is not unplayable due to this issue--nothing is physically happening that is making the game unplayable like in NCAA Basketball 10. There are thousands of people out there who don't even care that this bug exists and are enjoying this game.

        Also--the game plays without these issues minus the named rosters. If you are that bothered by the gameplay with the named rosters, delete them and play with the numbered rosters until the patch hits. Remember back in the PS1 days?

        Major oversight by EA? Possibly. Major inconvenience for us that want to start dynasty's? Yes. Gamebreaker? No.

        We just are stuck waiting for the patch--yes it sucks. End of story.
        None taken, I can handle people disagreeing with me. When guys are playing opposite of their intended tendency, it wrecks gameplay, ruins immersion, and it flat out isnt fun.

        To me, the game is unplayable, can I play with numbered rosters? Yes. But if I want to edit something as small as wristband I should be subjected to that players tendency flip flopping? I paid my money and I should be able to edit whomever I want however I want and if I want their tendency to change it should be because I want to, not some glitchy code.

        As for your PS1 comment, im not sure if that was satire or what. But im on PS3, taking advantage of todays technology. Why must I play like a "caveman" for errors on EA's end?

        You can compromise your gaming and make excuses for them, but I will not.

        Comment

        • ezio
          MVP
          • Jun 2003
          • 2853

          #424
          Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

          Originally posted by jenglund
          Autonaming rosters didn't change the tendencies for me last night. Actually, I just checked Denard Robinson...autonamed him and he remained a Scrambler. So, I'm pretty sure you could use fake names and not just numbers if you were so inclined.
          I may end up doing the auto-name. I just don't like the numbers

          Comment

          • aarontab
            Rookie
            • Mar 2011
            • 468

            #425
            Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

            Do you ever wonder if these EA people are sitting around laughing about this stuff? Some of it is so absurd and backwards that it seems like it would have to be intentional.

            And obviously, i know this is not the case. Those guys work hard and do the best they can to make a great game every year, just throwing out the hypothetical. It would be the best practical joke you could possibly play while collecting a salary.

            Comment

            • aliefallstar
              Rookie
              • Jul 2003
              • 464

              #426
              Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

              Originally posted by northface28
              I paid my money and I should be able to edit whomever I want however I want and if I want their tendency to change it should be because I want to, not some glitchy code.
              This bothers me, they owe you nothing.

              Comment

              • UMhester04
                MVP
                • Nov 2006
                • 1384

                #427
                Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                Originally posted by crabcola
                No offense, Bumble, when is the last time we weren't waiting on a patch for NCAA Football because of a major oversight like this one? It is something HUGE every year. It is just usually something different each time. And yes, for those who are interested more in the dynasty aspect of the game, this one is a BIG, BIG, oversight.

                You hit the nail right on the head, sir.

                Comment

                • northface28
                  Pro
                  • Jul 2009
                  • 762

                  #428
                  Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                  Originally posted by aarontab
                  Do you ever wonder if these EA people are sitting around laughing about this stuff? Some of it is so absurd and backwards that it seems like it would have to be intentional.

                  And obviously, i know this is not the case. Those guys work hard and do the best they can to make a great game every year, just throwing out the hypothetical. It would be the best practical joke you could possibly play while collecting a salary.
                  Lol, id do it to a friend, not thousands of consumers.

                  Comment

                  • JoeC
                    Look Watch
                    • Mar 2003
                    • 289

                    #429
                    Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                    I was just working on the defensive linemen. It looks like Pass Rushers are not affected much like Pocket Passers. I was looking at Quinton Coples and Donte Paige Moss on UNC and they are Pass Rushers on the edit and roster screen. What happens with DL is Run Stoppers are switching to balanced and Balanced to Run Stoppers. North Carolina DT Tydreke Powell is a run stopper in the edit screen but is shown as balanced in the roster screen. North Carolina DT Jordan Nix is shown as Balanced in the edit screen and as a run stopper in the roster screen. So it looks like pass rushers arent affected at all its just the balanced and run stuffers.

                    So does this look correct to everyone
                    QB- Pocket Passer not affected
                    Balanced-Scrambler
                    Scrambler-Balanced

                    RB- Power not affected?
                    Speed to Balanced
                    Balanced to Speed

                    WR- Possession not affected
                    Balanced to speed
                    speed to balanced

                    TE- Blocking not affected
                    Balanced to Receiving
                    Receiving to Balanced

                    OL- Run Block not affected
                    Pass Block to Balanced
                    Balanced to Pass Block

                    LB- Coverage not affected
                    Run Stopper to Balanced
                    Balanced to Run Stopper

                    DB- Coverage not affected
                    Balanced to hard hitter
                    hard hitter to balanced

                    So that is how it is messing with each position set minus the kickers and punters which I forgot to check. Everyone might know this info already but I was curious so I checked it and figured I would share what I found in hopes that it might help.
                    BCS Express - TCU (yr 1 12-1)(yr 2 10-2)

                    OsVets 1 - Texans
                    OSVets 2 - Raiders (9-7 afc west champs)
                    4th & 1 - 49ers

                    LOEG - Pittsburgh Penguins (11-8-4)

                    Comment

                    • FutureAUgrad
                      Rookie
                      • Jul 2011
                      • 30

                      #430
                      Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                      I only read about 15 pages of this thread and then a thought popped into my head. It seems like in my Troy dynasty something happened to change the tendency of my recruited quarterbacks. I didn't edit anything about them as far as I can remember. I was hoping that I could just play with unnamed rosters and in 4 years it would balance out as the recruits would all be named. I can't do this, however, if something is happening to change the tendencies of my recruited players. Has anyone else noticed this?

                      Comment

                      • UMhester04
                        MVP
                        • Nov 2006
                        • 1384

                        #431
                        Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                        So are we going to have to re-do all of our rosters? Are all the roster makers going to have to start over once this is patched? God help EA if this is true for the backlash they will recieve.

                        Comment

                        • aholbert32
                          (aka Alberto)
                          • Jul 2002
                          • 33106

                          #432
                          Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                          Originally posted by crabcola
                          No offense, Bumble, when is the last time we weren't waiting on a patch for NCAA Football because of a major oversight like this one? It is something HUGE every year. It is just usually something different each time. And yes, for those who are interested more in the dynasty aspect of the game, this one is a BIG, BIG, oversight.
                          I think its going a little overboard calling this HUGE or BIG, BIG. For me, HUGE is if it makes the game unplayable or the game is freezing. Its still an annoying issue no doubt.

                          Also, if this really happens every year then the blame starts to move over to the customer. What other product would you buy every year if you know that out of the box there would be issues and that you wouldnt be satisfied with the product until a month or two after you bought it? I know I cant think of one yet every year you guys rush in mass to buy the game Day 1.

                          Comment

                          • aholbert32
                            (aka Alberto)
                            • Jul 2002
                            • 33106

                            #433
                            Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                            Originally posted by UMhester04
                            So are we going to have to re-do all of our rosters? Are all the roster makers going to have to start over once this is patched? God help EA if this is true for the backlash they will recieve.
                            The backlash will have zero effect. Once the patch hits, people will go back to playing the game and they will buy the game again next year.

                            Comment

                            • aarontab
                              Rookie
                              • Mar 2011
                              • 468

                              #434
                              Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                              Originally posted by northface28
                              Lol, id do it to a friend, not thousands of consumers.
                              It almost seems that way though...case in point:

                              "Audio is super nice this year...especially the CROWD!!" - crowd is all but silent on default

                              "how about some diving catches?!?!" - very rare diving catches

                              "We invented a new button for tackling!" - Effing dive button, new name

                              Tendencies? Broken.
                              Suction/Warping? Still exists.
                              Defense already knows your play and audibles into perfect defenses along with you? Obviously.
                              Pass Interference? No, because eff you that's why.

                              And it could go on a few more, but i think we are all familiar with this stuff.

                              The saddest part is that i'm still excited to get out of work tonight and play this game lol.

                              Comment

                              • CarolinaCJAM
                                Rookie
                                • Jul 2011
                                • 76

                                #435
                                Re: NCAA Football 12 Possible Roster Glitch

                                I'm pretty much disgusted with EA by now. I guess all I can do is start playing a lot of online games to hold my attention until the patch comes out. And this patch better come out quick.

                                Comment

                                Working...