is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • eamuscatuli15
    Rookie
    • Oct 2009
    • 357

    #1

    is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

    Can someone clarify this roster glitch situation for me? haven't been able to play much or read much on here...does it affect game play or sim play?

    and if so is it best to use an unnamed roster right now for dynasty? i just like to start up a dynasty to play and get comfortable with the game since that's what i'll be spending all my time on during season...

    so i wanna play in dynasty with the most realistic rosters and gameplay out there right now?

    any help on these questions would be great
    MLB: Chicago Cubs
    NCAA Hoops: Georgetown Hoyas
    NBA: Los Angeles Lakers
    NFL: Kansas City Chiefs
    NCAA Football: Nebraska Cornhuskers
    HS Football: Rolla High School Bulldogs '95 (12-1)


  • vert56
    Banned
    • Jan 2011
    • 14

    #2
    Re: is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

    yes, EA has acknowledged it and is working on a fix.

    People saying that it does not exist are either working for EA or are trying so hard to like the game despite its being broken that they have engaged in a process of self-deception (as humans are prone to doing).

    NCAA Football 12 released with a number of serious problems that have been well documented which has prompted some response. Sadly add another to the running list with an issue that was discovered in named rosters. While the majority of the problems have thus far gone unaddressed by EA Sports this one is said to already

    Comment

    • vert56
      Banned
      • Jan 2011
      • 14

      #3
      Re: is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

      I think the guys/gals here at OS need to be better about filtering out the more speculative posts and highlight the facts.

      Otherwise we risk letting important issues slip through the cracks and/or get lost in the chaos of misinformation.

      THERE IS A GLITCH

      YOU CAN WORK AROUND IT IF YOU CHOOSE

      IT BETTER GET FIXED BECAUSE CURRENTLY THE GAME IS BROKEN

      Comment

      • eamuscatuli15
        Rookie
        • Oct 2009
        • 357

        #4
        Re: is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

        so right now the best thing to do to play a dynasty would be to just use the original game roster/ or is there a better roster out there has used a work around that is playable within dynasty mode?

        thanks for the help on this fellas...so busy with work that i'm not able to follow OS daily and stay up to date.
        MLB: Chicago Cubs
        NCAA Hoops: Georgetown Hoyas
        NBA: Los Angeles Lakers
        NFL: Kansas City Chiefs
        NCAA Football: Nebraska Cornhuskers
        HS Football: Rolla High School Bulldogs '95 (12-1)


        Comment

        • jbrew2411
          MVP
          • Dec 2007
          • 2554

          #5
          Re: is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

          For starters I don't work for EA sports, I'm a high school history teacher and coach. Their is a glitch with the roster were tendencies are being switched on the roster screen. An example is Michigan QB#16, D. Robinson, may show that he is listed as a "Scrambler" on the edit ratings page but on the roster page next to his name and under his height it will say he is a "Balanced" QB. It is happening at every position but only between 2 of the 3 tendencies with 1 tendency being left alone. For QB's it is the "Pocket Passers".

          Now how does this effect game play? Well in the game a player will react to his tendencies. So D-Rob, listed as "Balanced", will not tuck and run as much. Now makes some minor edits to his ratings, I upped his strength rating a few points and didn't raise his overall a single point, to make the roster screen to show him as a "Scrambler". Now D-Rob plays like he does on the numbered rosters. I spent about an hour editing all the QB's on named roster file I have. Now if I play against Michigan, cpu controlled, then D-Rob will run through holes when pressured.

          As for the recruits the problem shows up there as well. I have yet to get past the first season since I just started my dynasty. I will see how things go but I'm willing to spend a little time editing incoming recruits if I have too.

          I understand why some people may feel like this issue kills the game for them. As for me I remember that the names listed on the game are not the real people. It's a video game. With the right slider set this game is fun. I'm not going to wait a month to play a game I want to play now. Each gamer has to decide their own limits.
          Relax, it's just a video game!

          Comment

          • DPM19
            Rookie
            • Jun 2011
            • 15

            #6
            What NCAA is this?

            Sorry for being clueless ,but I'm assuming this is happening in NCAA 12 is this correct or is this something that came up in NCAA 11.

            Comment

            • BaylorBearBryant
              Sic 'em Bears!
              • Jun 2004
              • 1536

              #7
              Here's the main problem. The player tendencies of incoming recruits flip in dynasty. You're better off waiting to play your real dynasty when the patch comes out.




              Baylor Bears - Texans - Astros - Rockets - Avalanche


              Follow me on Twitch: twitch.tv/osovideo

              Comment

              • sirjam
                MVP
                • Oct 2002
                • 3535

                #8
                Re: is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

                It's nt jus qbs that it effects either. All positions get switched. Play a game without being signed in as your profile. Then be amazed at how much better the game is.

                Comment

                • HNIC Mike
                  Rookie
                  • Jul 2011
                  • 5

                  #9
                  Re: is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

                  Originally posted by sirjam
                  It's nt jus qbs that it effects either. All positions get switched. Play a game without being signed in as your profile. Then be amazed at how much better the game is.
                  yeah, i like it better when every CPU defender isnt trying to hit stick me

                  Comment

                  • sirjam
                    MVP
                    • Oct 2002
                    • 3535

                    #10
                    Re: is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

                    Originally posted by HNIC Mike
                    yeah, i like it better when every CPU defender isnt trying to hit stick me
                    Exactly. Nt every tackle needs to be jawbreaking

                    Comment

                    • ren6175
                      Rookie
                      • Aug 2007
                      • 36

                      #11
                      Re: is roster glitch real? need some help on this topic

                      Honestly, I don't recruit based on tendency, so I don't really care about them switching tendencies. So for me the game isn't broken. Of course I would like it to be fixed, but I'm still happy with the game and am playing my dynasty with named rosters. It is just a matter of opinion.

                      Comment

                      Working...