Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

[Steve_OS]

ESPN The Gamer has posted the Madden NFL 12 player ratings for the top 5 quarterbacks in the game.

Tom Brady - 99
Peyton Manning - 98
Aaron Rodgers - 98
Philip Rivers - 96
Drew Brees - 96

Are there any changes you would like to see, or are they just about right?

[Mike Smoove]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

Cant really argue with it although Peyton should be a 99. Looks spot on though. Glad Rivers is getting the respect he deserves as that guy is game.

[Yeah...THAT Guy]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

Looks ight to me although I think Rodgers and manning are just as good as Brady.

[dougdeuce]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

I'm so sick of seeing these inflated ratings. So after 3 years as a starter Rodgers can only get 1% better? Top 5 QB'S all above 95? Give me a break.

[angels eclipse7]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

I'm so sick of seeing these inflated ratings. So after 3 years as a starter Rodgers can only get 1% better? Top 5 QB'S all above 95? Give me a break.

I completely agree. 5 QBs 96 or higher? That is crazy. Donny wants to make every fan happy aka making every team a little better than they are.

[rich7sena]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

It would be nice for the ratings to reflect some perspective. For example, Manning is no longer at his best, I'd say he's playing around a 94 this far into his career. Rodgers is probably also around a 94 with a higher ceiling. Brady should be somewhere around a 97 because while he had a phenomenal season last year, he's not 2007 Brady which clearly was him at 99. I'd see the rankings something more like this:

Brady: 97
Manning: 94
Rodgers: 94
Brees: 94
Rivers: 92

I suppose overalls don't matter as long as their individual ratings are spot on.

[Elements]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

TOUCHE!!!

This so called Guru Ratings specialist must have been paid a little extra to blow up these guys stats. If I were in charge of these ratings you would see players who actually have flaws in their games, and some realistic value. When will we have a game that proves players are human. These stats are the equivalent to the first time you ever created a player, and made yourself 99 at everything.

Brady: 96
Manning: 95
Rodgers: 93
Brees: 91
Rivers:89

I've said this once, and I'll say it again. The 99 rating should be used sparingly. Designated for the best of the best, cream of the crop! No one in the past 10 years should have been given the 99 rating. Maybe a 98 for Brady in his 16-0 run a couple years back!

[knucklar]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

It would be nice for the ratings to reflect some perspective. For example, Manning is no longer at his best, I'd say he's playing around a 94 this far into his career. Rodgers is probably also around a 94 with a higher ceiling. Brady should be somewhere around a 97 because while he had a phenomenal season last year, he's not 2007 Brady which clearly was him at 99. I'd see the rankings something more like this:

Brady: 97
Manning: 94
Rodgers: 94
Brees: 94
Rivers: 92

I suppose overalls don't matter as long as their individual ratings are spot on.

I think if you bumped Rodgers up to a 95/96 those would be very fair ratings. Manning is coming off a rocky season by his standards and Rodgers just carried the Packers to a Super Bowl victory.

[Lange248]

I think those ratings are pretty good, at least they got the right QBs up there.

[BoricuaMobStar]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

Here's What I think the ratings should look like(Im going to do top 10 QB's though)

1. Tom Brady(96)
2. Payton Manning(96)
3. Arron Rodgers(94)
4. Drew Brees(90)
5. Phillip Rivers(90)
6. Michael Vick(87)
7. Matt Ryan(86)
8. Eli Manning (86)
9. Joe Flacco(84)
10. Mark Sanchez(84)

Idk it should be something like that. But overall ratings dont mean nothing anymore. It matters how u play not who u use

[poopoop]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

They should scrap overall ratings completely. Would do a lot of good and would allow players to be rated on their own merit instead of trying to make them a certain overall.

[chuckles012]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

Sanchez number 10? Hahahaha. I thought you were serious for a second.

[wishcoats]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

It would be nice for the ratings to reflect some perspective. For example, Manning is no longer at his best, I'd say he's playing around a 94 this far into his career. Rodgers is probably also around a 94 with a higher ceiling. Brady should be somewhere around a 97 because while he had a phenomenal season last year, he's not 2007 Brady which clearly was him at 99. I'd see the rankings something more like this:

Brady: 97
Manning: 94
Rodgers: 94
Brees: 94
Rivers: 92

I suppose overalls don't matter as long as their individual ratings are spot on.

Agreed. Some more perspective could be put into the ratings. But, as another poster said, I think they rather give high ratings to more people so fans of those teams don't feel cheated

[BoricuaMobStar]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

@Chuckles012 lol yeah he not top 10 material in real life but in the game u gonna have Santonio Homles, Braylon Edwards, and Plaxico Burress to throw to and you telling me they wont make a QB look good so Madden not gonna make him a top ten QB? In my book Sam Bradford way better and a few others.

[angels eclipse7]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Quarterbacks

They should scrap overall ratings completely. Would do a lot of good and would allow players to be rated on their own merit instead of trying to make them a certain overall.

i'd be pissed