Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Running Backs

[statum71]

Jamal Charles the third best back in the league???

Are you sure??????????

[Shroom]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Running Backs

I have to say, although I am a chargers fan, I think Charles deserves his rating. We are going to have a hell of a time stopping him this season.

[Smoke6]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Running Backs

What's this?

No Frank Gore?

I smell a conspiracy here, the man had a fractured hip and all and was still over a 1,000yds like 4 years in a row.

SMH!

[JJ_Bills9]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Running Backs

AP and Maurice Jones Drew are way too fast. Well, MJD is way too fast, and AP is about 3-5 points too fast.

[kwabalicious]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Running Backs

Eh, it was a weird deal. He didnt start games(they always put jones in the first series and charles the 2nd) but he would end up with more carries than jones the majority of games like a starter would of. I have no idea why they did that when charles was clearly the better back

I guess it's kind of like the NBA and this sixth man business. Like how on the spurs, Manu Ginobli clearly should be starting but the Spurs feel the need to bring him off the bench.

[marcoyk]

Arian Foster.

[Harrison_UNC_Barnes*]

Im glad to see Charles up there 95 is a little high maybe 1 92 would be more like it but hey im cool wit it..

[ybtherockstar]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Running Backs

Don't think charles should be that high. Maybe foster in his spot but everything else is good.

[Silentway]

Dang, Jamaal Charles?!? I know he was doing work in KC last year, but really?

Charles averaged 6.5 yards a carry last year, that's sick.

[Silentway]

All these people wondering if Charles should be that high obviously didn't watch the NFL last year, they must've just watched their hometown teams or the popular ones. Sigh... and I believe Hillis is a 91 not just as a running back but as blocker and I've never hardly seen a back with such ability to play wide-out.

[DeuceDouglas]

Stats over last 2 seasons:

Arian Foster
381 car. - 1873 yds. 19 TD, 4.8 avg.

Jamaal Charles
420 car. - 2587 yds. 12 TD, 6.1 avg.

End of Debate.

[DeuceDouglas]

Here's another little stat for ya:

Jamaal Charles over his last 20 games:

324 car. 2125 yds. 9 TD 6.55 avg.

[pootytang]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Ratings - Top 5 Running Backs

Stats over last 2 seasons:

Arian Foster
381 car. - 1873 yds. 19 TD, 4.8 avg.

Jamaal Charles
420 car. - 2587 yds. 12 TD, 6.1 avg.

End of Debate.

Hardly. Look at the TD totals.

Also It's convenient that you chose the last 2 years. In which the former Arian only played a couple games.

[DeuceDouglas]

Hardly. Look at the TD totals.

Also It's convenient that you chose the last 2 years. In which the former Arian only played a couple games.

Even if you look at this year's totals alone, Charles had only 149 less yards than Foster on 97 less carries. The TD totals are irrelevant because whenever the Chiefs got close to the end zone they would bring Thomas Jones in to finish off the drive. Foster had 10 TD's last year of three yards or less so there's where the difference in touchdown's comes.

[nyj721]

Even if you look at this year's totals alone, Charles had only 149 less yards than Foster on 97 less carries. The TD totals are irrelevant because whenever the Chiefs got close to the end zone they would bring Thomas Jones in to finish off the drive. Foster had 10 TD's last year of three yards or less so there's where the difference in touchdown's comes.

Charles is too high. He didn't even lead his team in carries last year.

I think it should be
1. AP
2. Chris Johnson
3. Stephen Jackson
4. MJD
5. Jamaal Charles

Not ready to but Foster in my top 5 yet because he only had 1 great year.