My games on All Pro and All Madden looked similar to his. That's a larger sample size. Reading everyone's impressions on All Pro and All Madden and seeing some of the stats they're posting increases the sample size. Going by how Madden has been historically increases the sample size for the series (maybe not 12, but for the series). Madden has a history of this.
I played on All Pro and All Madden, adjusting speed. I didn't adjust any other sliders, but that just tells me it's another year of fighting sliders to try and make things more realistic. Unfortunately, changing one slider to make something more realistic in Madden, tends to skew realism in another area.
Don't know how to respond to this. He gave his stats. Pretty much matched what I and others experienced. I would call that feedback.