Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

[ANDROMADA 1]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

He really is excellent. I think an 84 is good for him, especially considering nobody knows how he'll be coming back from his injury.

He should be fine. I hope so anyways. He always gave Dallas fits. Thats not really saying much these days though.

[NYwRiter94]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

He should be rated a lot higher than that. I would say 88-90 ish. Dude is an excellent player.

Definitely not. The guy's got hands like glue, and he runs ridiculous short routes, but he's not that fast and doesn't get many YAC. He's an elite slot receiver, but not a big play guy.

I never really understood what the toughness rating meant, but clearly they do it arbitrarily if Ahmad Bradshaw is a 78. The guy fights for EVERY single yard. In 2009 he ran for 800 yards as a backup with two broken feet, and last year ran for 1200 in a timeshare with a broken wrist and a sprained ankle. The guy's a monster.

I know he's not on the team anymore, but how the hell is Seubert 81? O'Hara sat out six games last year with an injury and when Seubert played center, Eli didn't get sacked a single time. The guy's a boss and never gets any credit.

Jernigan has 48 route running. How does a slot receiver drafted in the third round have 48 route running? Also how does Barden have a higher spectacular catch rating than Cruz?

They really hated on Kiwanuka--he was playing at least as well as Osi before he got injured. Sure, lower his injury rating, but don't make him crap.

I was pleasantly surprised with the 90 on Webster--I personally feel he's been underrated as a shutdown corner the past few years, but he's getting his recognition now. I actually am very impressed with the ratings for the secondary in general.

[crob8822]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

True True True...But sooner or later those last Cowboys sb videos will be in black and white. JUST SAYING

I have all 5 on DVD and they are in color, can't predict the future the championships just happen.

[crob8822]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

I look forward to playing with the boys in franchise mode.

[GoodImmigrant]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

so these rosters include practice squad players for franchise mode?


Quincy Carter For Cowboys QB

[MeanMrMustard]

Bruce Carter seems a bit low to me. I get not wanting to go overboard, since he's fresh off an injury, but the dude was a consensus first rounder until he got hurt. Doug Free's probably a bit low, too; he was a hot commodity this offseason.

Other than that, the Cowboys good on the whole. Not sure what has the haters up in arms... this team has a very bad secondary, a spotty offensive line w/o Leonard Davis, and absolutely nothing on the D-line after Ratliff. Doesn't seem like a case of EA overrating everyone.

[saintsyadig]

Bruce Carter 88 speed, 92 acceleration is cool. But Martez Wilson should be exactly the same or a lil faster. If not then something is wrong ea...

[RustyBlue]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

Definitely not. The guy's got hands like glue, and he runs ridiculous short routes, but he's not that fast and doesn't get many YAC. He's an elite slot receiver, but not a big play guy.

I never really understood what the toughness rating meant, but clearly they do it arbitrarily if Ahmad Bradshaw is a 78. The guy fights for EVERY single yard. In 2009 he ran for 800 yards as a backup with two broken feet, and last year ran for 1200 in a timeshare with a broken wrist and a sprained ankle. The guy's a monster.

I know he's not on the team anymore, but how the hell is Seubert 81? O'Hara sat out six games last year with an injury and when Seubert played center, Eli didn't get sacked a single time. The guy's a boss and never gets any credit.

Jernigan has 48 route running. How does a slot receiver drafted in the third round have 48 route running? Also how does Barden have a higher spectacular catch rating than Cruz?

They really hated on Kiwanuka--he was playing at least as well as Osi before he got injured. Sure, lower his injury rating, but don't make him crap.

I was pleasantly surprised with the 90 on Webster--I personally feel he's been underrated as a shutdown corner the past few years, but he's getting his recognition now. I actually am very impressed with the ratings for the secondary in general.

I agree with this, especially the Jernigan part.

[Stupendamatic]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

a lot of things wrong with the giants ratings

1. Eli being rated lower then Matt Schaub, Tony Romo and Joe Flacco

2. Steve Smith having a better juke/elusiveness rating then Hakeem Nicks

3. Shaun O'Hara's 92 rating, he only played a handful of games last year and played badly yet he is a 92? I guess they looked and saw he made the pro-bowl still (f'n joke) and rated him high.

4. Travis Beckum 71 rating, I have no clue how he went up around 10 points over the off-season wtf is that about?

5. Mathias Kiwanuka speed rating at 73, he is definitely at least an 80 for speed, not quite as fast as Osi/Tuck/JPP but he's fast for a DE this is like the 3rd straight year he has been screwed with his speed.

[phillysouljah]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

Kiwanuka is really a 79 now? Wow. Wasn't he knocking on 90 last year or was it the year before? I mean I know the guy was hurt and hasn't been as productive stat-wise as you'd think (only 3 sacks in 2009, for example), but 79 is a bit of a surprise for a guy still seen as a top DE on a different defense without Tuck and Umenyiora. Hell, he was starting over Umenyiora to start the season.

[R0M0mentum09]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

a lot of things wrong with the giants ratings

1. Eli being rated lower then Matt Schaub, Tony Romo and Joe Flacco

2. Steve Smith having a better juke/elusiveness rating then Hakeem Nicks

3. Shaun O'Hara's 92 rating, he only played a handful of games last year and played badly yet he is a 92? I guess they looked and saw he made the pro-bowl still (f'n joke) and rated him high.

4. Travis Beckum 71 rating, I have no clue how he went up around 10 points over the off-season wtf is that about?

5. Mathias Kiwanuka speed rating at 73, he is definitely at least an 80 for speed, not quite as fast as Osi/Tuck/JPP but he's fast for a DE this is like the 3rd straight year he has been screwed with his speed.

http://fifthdown.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/12/26/eli-manning-and-the-giants-interception-problem/

http://www.nfl.com/player/elimanning...96/careerstats

Man I wish Romo could throw over 20 picks twice and still somehow get an 85+ overall

[DorneyDave86]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

Ratings threads make me lol

[Jarodd21]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

They be killing me with having Webster and Thomas with LB speed. That is terrible. Both of there speed should at least be at 89. WRs don't be blowing by them like that for there speed to be that low and how did Kiwanuka's overrall drop from an 85 to a 79. He was in beast mode up until he get hurt. I wouldn't be complaining if he had of fell to an 83 or something but 79? Come on.. Manningham Speed should also be faster then a 92. 94 or 95 is where it should be.. Very disappointed in some of the ratings on the Giants..

[Stupendamatic]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

http://fifthdown.blogs.nytimes.com/2...ption-problem/

http://www.nfl.com/player/elimanning...96/careerstats

Man I wish Romo could throw over 20 picks twice and still somehow get an 85+ overall

Ahh yes typical casual fan basing opinions purely on stats

[R0M0mentum09]

Re: Madden NFL 12 Player Ratings - Dallas Cowboys and New York Giants

a lot of things wrong with the giants ratings

1. Eli being rated lower then Matt Schaub, Tony Romo and Joe Flacco

2. Steve Smith having a better juke/elusiveness rating then Hakeem Nicks

3. Shaun O'Hara's 92 rating, he only played a handful of games last year and played badly yet he is a 92? I guess they looked and saw he made the pro-bowl still (f'n joke) and rated him high.

4. Travis Beckum 71 rating, I have no clue how he went up around 10 points over the off-season wtf is that about?

5. Mathias Kiwanuka speed rating at 73, he is definitely at least an 80 for speed, not quite as fast as Osi/Tuck/JPP but he's fast for a DE this is like the 3rd straight year he has been screwed with his speed.

http://fifthdown.blogs.nytimes.com/2...ption-problem/

http://www.nfl.com/player/elimanning...96/careerstats

Man I wish Romo could throw over 20 picks twice and still somehow get an 85+ overall

Ahh yes typical casual fan basing opinions purely on stats

and I should be basing them on. . . ?