In your opinion Hal, the gameplay as improved. That's your opinion. I found that the gameplay this year was the worse I've seen for the last 3 years. I'm unable to play a game offline which I was doing in previous years because the AI is too dumb to my liking.
Did I play that game all year long? Yep, I did. Over a 1000 games online, maybe around 125 offline (previous years was aroun 500) and most nights, especially online, I had fun. It's just that offline, it's not been fun and it's cause the dev. team did a poor job with the AI.
I've bought NHL 2K10 just to see and the EA game is so much better in many areas that there's no comparison to make. Still, I can't understand how the little thing so much evident with the AI wasn't seen and corrected before going on the market.
Will I get NHL 12? You bet I will. I will expect a better gameplay offline and another great game (still with glitches and cheating but still fun) online. It's just like we all know it can be better and that's why it makes me so tough on EA at times.