Last year when I did my set
http://www.operationsports.com/forum...g-sliders.html with the coaching sliders, I took the time to give reasons why I did x and y.
But yes I hear ya.... too many guys just spout off what they 'deem' as correct without any evidence or any justifications.
I also did this for NBA2k11, except I did as you wanted, and made an entire thread just for explanations on the what, whys of the sliders. Much to my grin, that it did not pick up steam and feel off the main slider page...
I believe over at another NCAA football forum they have a slider section broken-down like that.