OK great this is what I figured. Try this instead and follow these steps.
Go to your settings and select allpro.
Now go into your player sliders and make sure everything is at 50. DO NOT TOUCH anything,
Then go into the CPU sliders and do the following.
Cpu Sliders: All at 53 , but broken tackles at 58, Fumbles at 43, Interception at 80, and Tackle at 38.
Fatigue:80
Injuries:27
Game speed: fast and threshold 50 or 75. Charter's last test indicated 75.
Go back to your settings and make sure skill level still indicates All Pro, if not then it was done wrong. It is very important that it says All pro.
Tell me if this played tougher? Thanks