I'm buyist, but I feel this is the best soccer game to ever be released. There, I said it.
The reason the AI is attacking a lot is because people try to play PES like Fifa (aggressive, going for the tackle to quickly instead of holding up play).
PES also has a contain button on defense (had it last year also before Fifa) and if you use it, you can very easily hold up play. Watch a CPU vs CPU game to show this.
Video game reviews are subjective and I agree with a lot of what you said, but I respectfully disagree about Fifa gaining a higher score.
Especially considering the gripes you made about Fifa.
I appreciate how balanced you were, but I feel like the reviews you wrote give two completely different scores than what you actually rated and talked about.
Gameplay wins outright every time and going by what you wrote -- PES should've won.
(I feel like a lawyer resting his case.)