Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

[NFCastle]

Disclaimer: Yes I am aware that some of these trades would never happen IRL, but if you were to assume ANYONE is dealable, do these seem fair/around the right price.

Trying to reunite some of the Florida offense here in Miami.

Trade 1: Get Maurkice Pouncey
Steelers desperately need to improve their secondary, so I was thinking along these lines...
Vontae Davis (Cb) 87 overall I beleive, young + 1st round pick+ 3rd round pick for Maurkice Pouncey & Marcus Gilbert

Trade 2: Get Percy Harvin
Brandon Marshall+ a 2nd round pick from next year+ a 4th round pick this year

Trade 3: Get Tebow
Chad Henne, could be a solid backup to orton or whoever denver decides to be their starter + 3rd round pick from next year+ 5th round pick this year

Oveall Id be dealing out
Vontae Davis, Brandon Marshall, Chad Henne, 1st, 3rd,4th,5th round picks from this year, 2nd, 3rd next year

to get

Maurkice Pouncey, Marcus Gilbert, Percy Harvin, Tim Tebow



Any suggestions on what I could do to make these trades more fair/better deals, or opinions on what I have listed?
Other players I could deal?

[mjhyankees]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

Disclaimer: Yes I am aware that some of these trades would never happen IRL, but if you were to assume ANYONE is dealable, do these seem fair/around the right price.

Trying to reunite some of the Florida offense here in Miami.

Trade 1: Get Maurkice Pouncey
Steelers desperately need to improve their secondary, so I was thinking along these lines...
Vontae Davis (Cb) 87 overall I beleive, young + 1st round pick+ 3rd round pick for Maurkice Pouncey & Marcus Gilbert

Trade 2: Get Percy Harvin
Brandon Marshall+ a 2nd round pick from next year+ a 4th round pick this year

Trade 3: Get Tebow
Chad Henne, could be a solid backup to orton or whoever denver decides to be their starter + 3rd round pick from next year+ 5th round pick this year

Oveall Id be dealing out
Vontae Davis, Brandon Marshall, Chad Henne, 1st, 3rd,4th,5th round picks from this year, 2nd, 3rd next year

to get

Maurkice Pouncey, Marcus Gilbert, Percy Harvin, Tim Tebow



Any suggestions on what I could do to make these trades more fair/better deals, or opinions on what I have listed?
Other players I could deal?

Hard for me to say, because as you said it's not real life. You could do a chise with a fantasy draft and draft these guys instead of making trades. Otherwise just give the cpu what it asks for with each guy.

[Jags4Lyfe]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

I like to build through the draft

[xblake16x]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

More than secondary help, the Steelers actually need offensive lineman.

[37]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

Trades #2 and #3 seem reasonable.....#1 seems sketchy.....ur right..Pitt's secondary is atrocious but they been plugging in bums at CB for a while now....but u don't weaken an already suspect O-line to fill a hole at CB.....I understand u wanna do the whole re-uniting thing but if u TRULY wanna be fair, i would hold off on trade #1 unless u can throw in a good O-lineman or two

[Jags4Lyfe]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

you already have Mike Pouncey why do you need both Pouncey brothers? Oh I get it...your a Gator fan like me...Spurrier already tried this once....it didn't work

[scoonie05]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

No!!!! The first thing u need is a QB. U have a pouncey already u don't need another. Then build on LG and RT.

[Jags4Lyfe]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

you could always trade Carey, Bell, Henne, and Taylor for Picks

[37]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

No!!!! The first thing u need is a QB. U have a pouncey already u don't need another. Then build on LG and RT.

OP is only interested in forming a Florida connection

[37]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

you could always trade Carey, Bell, Henne, and Taylor for Picks

None of them would bring u back anything significant unless u want a boatload of 4th's and 5ths

[NFCastle]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

Thanks for the feedback everyone, appreciate that everything has been constructive rather than just pointing out what I already know that it isnt real life :P


Seems like concensus is to leave maurkice in pgh, that's fair, their o line is already suspect as pointed out

Carey/bell/taylor for picks are possibilities, considering wake as well.


Any more feedback is appreciated about what I could do to make things better deals/ other players I could deal out for picks and whatnot

[37]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

Thanks for the feedback everyone, appreciate that everything has been constructive rather than just pointing out what I already know that it isnt real life :P


Seems like concensus is to leave maurkice in pgh, that's fair, their o line is already suspect as pointed out

Carey/bell/taylor for picks are possibilities, considering wake as well.


Any more feedback is appreciated about what I could do to make things better deals/ other players I could deal out for picks and whatnot

Fasano, Incognito, Colombo could go as well...Personally i'd keep Carey...guy is a 90 OVR and 30 is not over-the-hill for a lineman......only way i'd see getting rid of him is for salary relief.....never been a big Kevin Burnett guy...i'd trade him to either the Chargers for Donald Butler or the Cards for Daryl Washington...of course i'd have to throw in a pick or two..depending on which roster update ur using, i'd trade either slaton or bush...they have the same skill set and unless ur moving reggie full-time to WR, there's no use for both of em

[poopoop]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

So you want to rebuild the Dolphins by trading away 4/6 of your 1st/2nd/3rd round picks for the next 2 years.

None of the trades really are a huge upgrade for you and in some cases they are a downgrade: Marshall + picks for Harvin.

It seems more than anything like you're a Florida fan trying to get all the young former Florida players you can find, which is fine, but I don't think it's the best way to go about rebuilding. I'd rather keep my picks.

[37]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

So you want to rebuild the Dolphins by trading away 4/6 of your 1st/2nd/3rd round picks for the next 2 years.

None of the trades really are a huge upgrade for you and in some cases they are a downgrade: Marshall + picks for Harvin.

It seems more than anything like you're a Florida fan trying to get all the young former Florida players you can find, which is fine, but I don't think it's the best way to go about rebuilding. I'd rather keep my picks.

and keep Marshall....big, gifted, proven WR's don't grow on trees....No need to touch MIA's WR corps....U can work with them

[89OneHanded]

Re: Rebuilding Miami, have a few trades in mind

Tebow is a downgrade from Henne as well. And no, that is not sarcasm. Sorry Florida fans. NFL H-Back, not NFL Quarterback.