 |
Quote: |
 |
|
|
 |
Originally Posted by havokeff |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reading this list, it looks like Master Chief Syndrom creeping in.
"Why can't I make that throw?! I should be able to make that throw!!!"
The ratings in Madden, like or dislike, force you to play up to them.
Reggie Bush is a perimeter runner. His tackle breaking is low, his BCV is low, his carrying is low.
Therefore, he shouldn't be running between the tackles trying to find holes against guys with 80-99 tackling.
He needs to be outside running in open space where BCV isn't as important an tacklers are in the 50-79 range and he has less chance of fumbling.
This article IMO reflect the general lack of knowing football that 90% of players have.
"Ronde Barber gets beat deep and in man to man".
No crap Sherlock. He is a Cover Two corner, but it sounds like the writer of this has no idea what that means.
"Shawn Merriman can only rush the passer."
Yeah... AND? That is what Shawn Merriman has always been. A Pass rush specialist. He is 90% of the time the blitzing LB in a 3-4. If the author understood defenses, he would understand THAT.
"Kolb can't pass deep. Larry Fitzgerald needs a deep passer."
WHAT?! Fitz is an AMAZING reciever, but he is not a "deep threat" receiver. He is like Jerry Rice and Chris Carter. He catches short to medium passes and takes them the distance. Yes, he can catch the occasional deep ball, but it is not his game.
"Mike Williams is slow and not elusive."
POSSESSION RECEIVER. Does this author realize that not every receiver in the NFL is DeSean Jackson?
This article is pathetic and illustrates the contradicting personality of the majority of the Madden "Community" and the fact that when presented WITH realism, they can't handle it because they don't understand football.
"I WANT REALISM. I WANT THE NFL ON MY XBOX!!"
"OMG!!! RONDE BARBER CAN'T MAN UP ON ANDRE JOHNSON!! HE SUCKS!! HOW IS HE AN 85?!?!"
El oh el.
|
|
 |
|
 |
|
I agree with everything you mentioned, EXCEPT for the Fitz opinion. For you to criticize the guy for "not knowing football" you've seemed to miss on this point.
No, Larry Fitz isn't a "deep threat" in the mold of a DeSean Jackson, Devin Hester/Johnny Knox, Torrey Smith, etc. But he CAN go up and get it (a concept that still hasn't been properly executed in Madden) just like Cris Carter, Randy Moss, currently guys like Dez Bryant and even Steve Smith (Who I think is one of the best WRs at going up and getting the ball at it's highest point), and he also gets separation consistently due to his size. This being said, you need a guy who can put the ball in a spot where the WR can go get it, whether it be in a jump ball situation (which isn't that hard) or over the defender that is most likely trailing the WR. QBs don't just chuck it and pray; part of the reason Randy Moss had that 23 TD season was because Tom Brady is an extraordinary deep ball passer. Aaron Rodgers is having the year he's having because of his ability to throw it to SPOTS downfield to allow the WRs to go get them.