Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TheSaints7
    • Sep 2025

    #1

    Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

    Here are the options to choose from.

    Drew Brees - New Orleans Saints
    Tom Brady - New England Patriots
    Ben Roethlisberger - Pittsburgh Steelers
    Peyton Manning - Indianapolis Colts
    Aaron Rodgers -Green Bay Packers

    Simply arrange them into a list on your favourite and the ones you think are the best in game. 1 being the best and 5 being the worst.
    My list
    1. Drew Brees
    2. Aaron Rodgers
    3. Ben Roethlisberger
    4. Peyton Manning
    5. Tom Brady
    Post yours
  • WFColonel56
    Pro
    • Feb 2009
    • 620

    #2
    Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

    Originally posted by TheSaints7
    Here are the options to choose from.

    Drew Brees - New Orleans Saints
    Tom Brady - New England Patriots
    Ben Roethlisberger - Pittsburgh Steelers
    Peyton Manning - Indianapolis Colts
    Aaron Rodgers -Green Bay Packers

    Simply arrange them into a list on your favourite and the ones you think are the best in game. 1 being the best and 5 being the worst.
    My list
    1. Drew Brees
    2. Aaron Rodgers
    3. Ben Roethlisberger
    4. Peyton Manning
    5. Tom Brady
    Post yours
    1. ARod
    2. Brees
    3. Big Ben
    4. Brady
    5. Manning

    honestly Arod is leaps and bounds above all the others as far as madden is concerned. His mobility+ accuracy is out of this world

    Brees is 2nd because of accuracy. I dnt know the ratings but he throws a better ball in my opinion than everyone on the list. Big Ben's mobility has him at number 3. Brady and manning are the same guy pretty much, and they are dead in the pocket if they ever have to escape a pass rush

    Comment

    • tarantism
      Pro
      • Apr 2009
      • 979

      #3
      Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

      Matt Ryan! Screw the Saints.
      GO FALCONS!

      Originally posted by Tweeg
      In all of the pre release CCM news people like Looman kept saying, "You might see a guy like Kurt Warner come out of retirement. Anything can happen."

      He should have said "You will see Kurt Warner come out of retirement. That's about it."

      Comment

      • TheSaints7

        #4
        Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

        Originally posted by tarantism
        Matt Ryan! Screw the Saints.
        Just because we won! HAHA

        Comment

        • tarantism
          Pro
          • Apr 2009
          • 979

          #5
          Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

          Originally posted by TheSaints7
          Just because we won! HAHA
          Nope. I have hated the 'aints for years and years, bag head.
          GO FALCONS!

          Originally posted by Tweeg
          In all of the pre release CCM news people like Looman kept saying, "You might see a guy like Kurt Warner come out of retirement. Anything can happen."

          He should have said "You will see Kurt Warner come out of retirement. That's about it."

          Comment

          • Dianwei32
            Pro
            • Sep 2008
            • 903

            #6
            Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

            It seems odd to ask who our top 5 are and then give us a list of who we can choose from....

            1. Aaron Rodgers
            2. Peyton Manning
            3. Drew Brees
            4. Tom Brady
            T-5. Michael Vick
            T-5. Philip Rivers

            I don't believe that Fat Ben (I refuse to call him Big Ben... I'm bigger than him, he's just fat) is top-5 material. Rivers would have been #5 over a tie with Vick, but with his struggles this year I had to knock him down a bit.

            Comment

            • il blood il
              Rookie
              • Nov 2009
              • 419

              #7
              Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

              are we talking madden or IRL? cuz in madden, you gotta put cam newton in this mix...hes a monster...

              Comment

              • at23steelers
                Pro
                • Dec 2009
                • 950

                #8
                Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

                Originally posted by Dianwei32
                It seems odd to ask who our top 5 are and then give us a list of who we can choose from....

                1. Aaron Rodgers
                2. Peyton Manning
                3. Drew Brees
                4. Tom Brady
                T-5. Michael Vick
                T-5. Philip Rivers

                I don't believe that Fat Ben (I refuse to call him Big Ben... I'm bigger than him, he's just fat) is top-5 material. Rivers would have been #5 over a tie with Vick, but with his struggles this year I had to knock him down a bit.
                You know this in in Madden right? Btw, you having Vick and Rivers over Big Ben IRL is either complete homerism for both of those QB's or complete hatred for Big Ben.
                Have an awesome day!!

                Comment

                • tarantism
                  Pro
                  • Apr 2009
                  • 979

                  #9
                  Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

                  Agree with the above. Michael Vick is just an average quarterback with a huge reputation. He would struggle to crack my top 10 in real life. In madden though he has always been strong.
                  GO FALCONS!

                  Originally posted by Tweeg
                  In all of the pre release CCM news people like Looman kept saying, "You might see a guy like Kurt Warner come out of retirement. Anything can happen."

                  He should have said "You will see Kurt Warner come out of retirement. That's about it."

                  Comment

                  • HadlerT
                    Pro
                    • Sep 2011
                    • 664

                    #10
                    Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

                    Are we talking about in Madden? If so:

                    1.) Aaron Rodgers- Almost PERFECT player, w/ mobillity, accuracy, throw strength, you name it.

                    2.) Drew Brees - Have always thought he was better than Brady & Manning. Most accurate passer IMO.

                    3.) Tom Brady - Above average Accuracy, and Throw Strength.

                    4.) Peyton Manning - Manning has SUPERB accuracy, mixed with his throw power, is good enough for #4

                    5.) Tie: between Ben Roethlesberger(sp?) and Eli Manning.

                    Eli just is not the best at one thing, but above average at everything.

                    Ben has the mobility, cannon, and the accuracy.
                    Seattle Mariners|Seattle Seahawks

                    Comment

                    • Obnoxious
                      MVP
                      • Sep 2011
                      • 1134

                      #11
                      Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

                      I'm going to post the best I like playing in the game, not the best in the league.


                      5. Tim Tebow
                      4. Matt Stafford
                      3. Justin Thorpe (Rookie from my FCS JMU team dynasty)
                      2. Jake Locker
                      1. Drew Brees

                      Comment

                      • TheSaints7

                        #12
                        Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

                        Originally posted by tarantism
                        Nope. I have hated the 'aints for years and years, bag head.
                        Yes, because we win you all the time, "Bag head*".

                        Comment

                        • TheSaints7

                          #13
                          Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

                          Guys you can post your top 5 Quarterbacks in Madden then. It does not have to be the ones listed in the OP.

                          Comment

                          • Minnesota Red Sox
                            Rookie
                            • Dec 2007
                            • 99

                            #14
                            Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

                            1. Rodgers
                            2. Brady
                            3. Brees
                            4. Romo
                            5. Schaub

                            Comment

                            • 12
                              Banned
                              • Feb 2010
                              • 4458

                              #15
                              Re: Your top 5 Quarterbacks?

                              Originally posted by TheSaints7
                              Here are the options to choose from.

                              Drew Brees - New Orleans Saints
                              Tom Brady - New England Patriots
                              Ben Roethlisberger - Pittsburgh Steelers
                              Peyton Manning - Indianapolis Colts
                              Aaron Rodgers -Green Bay Packers

                              Simply arrange them into a list on your favourite and the ones you think are the best in game. 1 being the best and 5 being the worst.
                              My list
                              1. Drew Brees
                              2. Aaron Rodgers
                              3. Ben Roethlisberger
                              4. Peyton Manning
                              5. Tom Brady
                              Post yours
                              1. Rodgers
                              2a. Brady
                              2b. Brees
                              4. Roethlisberger
                              5. Manning (not sure why he's on this list)

                              If I had a choice between 5 QB's to play with...

                              1. Tebow
                              2. Locker
                              3. Cam Newton
                              4. Rodgers
                              5. Brees

                              ...just for the fun factor. I think Tebow, Locker and Newton would be a blast to play with because they're young and all three have promise. I don't like playing with established QB's as much.

                              Comment

                              Working...