Mustangs84/Community Roster

[Mustangs84]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

not sure if thats the intent behind the Mustang rosters. I think it was done just to give us accurate college rosters. I don't think any tweaking was done with consideration for draft potential. For that head to the Madden forum and check out Cursive or Herky. I think they used Mustang's rosters as a template to build rosters with the intention of creating draft classes.

This is pretty spot on. I did take draft potential into consideration when doing ratings, but not to the extent needed to make a truly accurate draft class. For truly accurate draft classes, I would have had to switch some positions around (DE's to 3-4 OLB, DT's to 3-4 DE, etc) and would have had to crank down some of the classic great college players who don't project to the pro's (ie. Kellen Moore).

[bannedkt]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Great job with the rosters, Mustangs. Here's a couple things I would consider:

REMOVE MICHIGAN WR DARRYL STONUM

Darryl Stonum was dismissed from the team earlier this week, and will not be returning. He did not play a single minute in the 2011 season because he was suspended, but was expected to come back for the 2012 season as a RS Senior. On the community roster he was removed from the depth chart but left on the roster. He should be removed all together, as he is simply taking up a roster spot when in fact he played his final game for the Michigan Wolverines in 2010 (excluding the Gator Bowl on Jan. 1, 2011).

SS Jared Van Slyke, a RS Senior, #31, 6'2", 195 lbs. white kid from Missouri, should, in my opinion, be his replacement. Van Slyke got playing time in 12 out of 13 games in 2011, but is not in the game. Another option: CB Tony Anderson (overall 74-76), who saw action in a couple of games, mostly on Special Teams. He is black (no dreads), RS Senior, #17, 5'11", 195 lbs. from California. The only problem is that WR Jeremy Jackson is already #17. Other options (in order of importance): RT Erik Gunderson, C/LT Joey Burzynski, RB Michael Cox, K/P Seth Broekhuizen. I would go with Van Slyke (overall 79-81).

Also, consider replacing Freshman C Jack Miller with Burzynski (overall 73-75). Burzynski saw some playing time this year and is currently higher on the depth chart, yet Miller is the one in the game. I realize it is important to have some freshmen, but Burzynski was a RS Freshman himself this year, and Gunderson was a RS Sophomore, although he is not a center. Seth Broekhuizen was our K/P a couple years back, but has since fallen behind Wile, Gibbons, and Hagerup, so I would not recommend putting a fourth K/P on the roster. Mike Cox is a decent back, but considering there are already five RBs on the roster, I would avoid him as well.

Also, I would consider boosting Denard Robinson's speed up to a 96. I know draft scout has him at a 4.39 second 40 time, but I would say that his average is about a 4.32, with a low of 4.30. He's one of the most explosive players in college football history. I think he deserves a higher speed.

Again, great job.

[loccdogg26]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Great job with the rosters, Mustangs. Here's a couple things I would consider:

REMOVE MICHIGAN WR DARRYL STONUM

Darryl Stonum was dismissed from the team earlier this week, and will not be returning. He did not play a single minute in the 2011 season because he was suspended, but was expected to come back for the 2012 season as a RS Senior. On the community roster he was removed from the depth chart but left on the roster. He should be removed all together, as he is simply taking up a roster spot when in fact he played his final game for the Michigan Wolverines in 2010 (excluding the Gator Bowl on Jan. 1, 2011).

SS Jared Van Slyke, a RS Senior, #31, 6'2", 195 lbs. white kid from Missouri, should, in my opinion, be his replacement. Van Slyke got playing time in 12 out of 13 games in 2011, but is not in the game. Another option: CB Tony Anderson (overall 74-76), who saw action in a couple of games, mostly on Special Teams. He is black (no dreads), RS Senior, #17, 5'11", 195 lbs. from California. The only problem is that WR Jeremy Jackson is already #17. Other options (in order of importance): RT Erik Gunderson, C/LT Joey Burzynski, RB Michael Cox, K/P Seth Broekhuizen. I would go with Van Slyke (overall 79-81).

Also, consider replacing Freshman C Jack Miller with Burzynski (overall 73-75). Burzynski saw some playing time this year and is currently higher on the depth chart, yet Miller is the one in the game. I realize it is important to have some freshmen, but Burzynski was a RS Freshman himself this year, and Gunderson was a RS Sophomore, although he is not a center. Seth Broekhuizen was our K/P a couple years back, but has since fallen behind Wile, Gibbons, and Hagerup, so I would not recommend putting a fourth K/P on the roster. Mike Cox is a decent back, but considering there are already five RBs on the roster, I would avoid him as well.

Also, I would consider boosting Denard Robinson's speed up to a 96. I know draft scout has him at a 4.39 second 40 time, but I would say that his average is about a 4.32, with a low of 4.30. He's one of the most explosive players in college football history. I think he deserves a higher speed.

Again, great job.

He is also a Michigan fan so he may or may not agree
with you.

[Mustangs84]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Great job with the rosters, Mustangs. Here's a couple things I would consider:

REMOVE MICHIGAN WR DARRYL STONUM

Darryl Stonum was dismissed from the team earlier this week, and will not be returning. He did not play a single minute in the 2011 season because he was suspended, but was expected to come back for the 2012 season as a RS Senior. On the community roster he was removed from the depth chart but left on the roster. He should be removed all together, as he is simply taking up a roster spot when in fact he played his final game for the Michigan Wolverines in 2010 (excluding the Gator Bowl on Jan. 1, 2011).

SS Jared Van Slyke, a RS Senior, #31, 6'2", 195 lbs. white kid from Missouri, should, in my opinion, be his replacement. Van Slyke got playing time in 12 out of 13 games in 2011, but is not in the game. Another option: CB Tony Anderson (overall 74-76), who saw action in a couple of games, mostly on Special Teams. He is black (no dreads), RS Senior, #17, 5'11", 195 lbs. from California. The only problem is that WR Jeremy Jackson is already #17. Other options (in order of importance): RT Erik Gunderson, C/LT Joey Burzynski, RB Michael Cox, K/P Seth Broekhuizen. I would go with Van Slyke (overall 79-81).

Also, consider replacing Freshman C Jack Miller with Burzynski (overall 73-75). Burzynski saw some playing time this year and is currently higher on the depth chart, yet Miller is the one in the game. I realize it is important to have some freshmen, but Burzynski was a RS Freshman himself this year, and Gunderson was a RS Sophomore, although he is not a center. Seth Broekhuizen was our K/P a couple years back, but has since fallen behind Wile, Gibbons, and Hagerup, so I would not recommend putting a fourth K/P on the roster. Mike Cox is a decent back, but considering there are already five RBs on the roster, I would avoid him as well.

Also, I would consider boosting Denard Robinson's speed up to a 96. I know draft scout has him at a 4.39 second 40 time, but I would say that his average is about a 4.32, with a low of 4.30. He's one of the most explosive players in college football history. I think he deserves a higher speed.

Again, great job.

Ya, I removed Stonum already. I turned him into Van Slyke, mainly because there wasn't a better option. However, I made him a 73 overall. 79-81 is much too high for a walk-on who contributed mkainly on special teams in his career.

As far as Miller, I'm not going to be removing him. At this point he is the only true underclassmen at center...that's even taking into account the incoming 2012 recruits. Meanwhile, Burzynsyki and Gunderson are both walkons, and with the 2012 OL class looking pretty stellar (especially if they manage to snag Garnett), neither of those guys are likely to see significant playing time at Michigan.

I've also debated removing Terrence Talbott, considering he barely played this year, and replacing him with Tamani Carter. Minor move, but probably makes sense.

[mkharsh33]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

mustangs... you planning on uploading one more "final" roster?? Would be cool if you did... If so, I'll wait, but I'm planning to get more into this game now that my NBA 2K11 rosters have pretty much taken shape.

Thanks for all you do...guys like you (and many others) make this community here at OS great!!

[boweezy21]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Mustang, can you put this file online to download with usb. The PS3 servers are down, and I want to get started with your rosters.

[mkharsh33]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Mustang, can you put this file online to download with usb. The PS3 servers are down, and I want to get started with your rosters.

You are aware these are for the 360, correct?

[bannedkt]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Okay, thank you. And Mustangs, come July, will you be doing another roster for NCAA Football 13?

[BCJMU99]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

NIIIIICE rosters Mustang!! Did you re-rate at all? Been awhile since I played and I downloaded them and briefly looked at the last night. UVA squad looks great!

[cableant]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Mustang84's Roster file for offline users. (as of 1/25/12)

Here

Seen a few people requesting them, just started playing this again.
Thanks for the rosters.

--Not sure how to use the file follow the link below--

Guide to transferring Roster files to USB flash drive (X360 Users)

[bannedkt]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

I tried downloading the roster again and there is still Darryl Stonum, so I'm guessing you haven't uploaded the new roster...when will it be uploaded?

[jgangstahippie7:18]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

I am looking forward to the next update.
Will the next update be the last one?
Waiting to export draft classes.

[Mustangs84]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Hey fellas. I do plan on releasing another update...in fact, it's pretty much done. However, my Xbox has recently decided it will only play certain games, and NCAA isn't one of them. I'm pretty sure it's a laser issue.

Anyways, hold tight for a bit. I plan on picking up a new unit before the weeknd's done, so I'll have something for you over the next week.

[johnp666]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Hey im not reading through all these pages, is this roster for the 2012-13 season or for last season.

[Mustangs84]

Re: Mustangs84/Community Roster

Hey im not reading through all these pages, is this roster for the 2012-13 season or for last season.

This past season. I'd be a wizard to get out a roster for next year already....