Here is the list of deserving players based on my own criteria of performance, impact, watchability, and success.
Eli Manning
Terell Suggs
Tim Tebow
Justin Smith
Drew Brees
Ray Lewis
Victor Cruz
Aaron Rogers
Patrick Willis
James Harrison
Marshawn Lynch
Calvin Johnson
Mathew Stafford
DeMarcus Ware
Rob Gronkowski
Vernon Davis
Arian Foster
D'Qwell Jackson
Jason Piere-Paul
Jarred Allen
Jordy Nelson
All these guys have at least 3-4 of my criteria in spades.
That said, I would like to see Madden go with themes instead of one single player. It's time to recognize that it takes more than one guy to make a team successful.
If you go that way, this year would be a perfect time to go with either a Front Seven theme or a Passing Attack theme.
F7: Paul, Allen, Smith, Suggs, Willis, Jackson, Ware
PA: Brees, Cruz, Gronkowski, Johnson, Davis and Nelson
Now that said, it is hard to argue against Tebow. There wasn't a more divisive, discussed, emulated or showcased athlete in any sport this year.
He also has 3 1/4 out of my 4 criteria.


Comment