MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

[JayNY]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

I hate to be that guy but for Rafael Soriano to be rated higher than Curtis Granderson and and Dave Robertson... I don't know.

[MC2]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

I hate to be that guy but for Rafael Soriano to be rated higher than Curtis Granderson and and Dave Robertson... I don't know.

Exactly. Soriano's great, but he missed most of last season, and when he was around, didn't do much.

While Curtis Granderson was one of the best hitters last year and Dave Robertson is a lights out pitcher.

[metsfan4life1]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

A "number 4 starter on a winning team" is a little different than the third best player overall on a team. You just reinforced his statement.

He's not.. This is a video game we're talking about. In real life he's not in the top 5.

[mr9inchesbpel]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

As a Mets fan I'm disappointed to see that Tim Byrdak is considered to be a better player then Ike Davis, Lucas Duda and Daniel Murphy.

All 3 of those guys were pretty good when they were playing last year and I hope that because of injuries or not being to well known and young that are rated low.

[mr9inchesbpel]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

As a Mets fan, looking at the Top 9 for our team is so depressing...

If Daniel Murphy, Ike Davis, and Lucas Duda continue to play like they were last season or improve as they should and stay healthy they should all be ranked towards the top of the team.

[metsfan4life1]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

As a Mets fan I'm disappointed to see that Tim Byrdak is considered to be a better player then Ike Davis, Lucas Duda and Daniel Murphy.

All 3 of those guys were pretty good when they were playing last year and I hope that because of injuries or not being to well known and young that are rated low.

I couldn't agree more!! No Ike or murph or Duda in the top nine.. SMH. At least murph or Ike should've been there. They've had the most experience. If I don't edit them to where they should be, I would have just another 1B with power and some useless 2B because his D is bad and he's underrated as a hitter. Duda probably has good pop, but his Average and plate discipline are probably really low.. When Dudas a guy who shows patience and doesn't strike out a lot, as a matter of fact.

[mr9inchesbpel]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

I couldn't agree more!! No Ike or murph or Duda in the top nine.. SMH. At least murph or Ike should've been there. They've had the most experience. If I don't edit them to where they should be, I would have just another 1B with power and some useless 2B because his D is bad and he's underrated as a hitter. Duda probably has good pop, but his Average and plate discipline are probably really low.. When Dudas a guy who shows patience and doesn't strike out a lot, as a matter of fact.

Hoping that by opening day they change some of the attributes or that these guys have good seasons so the Mets can actually be good in real life and so they get their attributes boosted up.





Also another thing but I think they should put any non closing relief pitchers lower on this list. An expandable reliever who gives you a 3.50 era can have a good overall in the game but is by no means as good a player as a 300+ hitting good defensive 1st baseman.

[metsfan4life1]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

Hoping that by opening day they change some of the attributes or that these guys have good seasons so the Mets can actually be good in real life and so they get their attributes boosted up.





Also another thing but I think they should put any non closing relief pitchers lower on this list. An expandable reliever who gives you a 3.50 era can have a good overall in the game but is by no means as good a player as a 300+ hitting good defensive 1st baseman.

Ike was on pace to have better numbers than Pujols last year, they should factor that in too. I mean, without editing Ike, heeill be just a slightly above average 1B with some pop, and ey portably haven't recognized his great glove at 1B yet. And murph was Having a great year as a hitter. Yet it looks like he'll be rated as some bench player that would pinch hit. And Duda was great last year offensively! And he, because he doesn't have a good glove or speed, would be useless because he could only hit HRs and they most likely gave him low contact.. He hit 292 I think last year.. In 390+ at bats.

[metsfan4life1]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

Hoping that by opening day they change some of the attributes or that these guys have good seasons so the Mets can actually be good in real life and so they get their attributes boosted up.





Also another thing but I think they should put any non closing relief pitchers lower on this list. An expandable reliever who gives you a 3.50 era can have a good overall in the game but is by no means as good a player as a 300+ hitting good defensive 1st baseman.

But they don't edit attributes.. I don't think so. 2Ks great at this, but the show lacks at actually updating the attributes.

[ZOMB13AUTOPILOT]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

Look at his numbers last year, they were really good. His ratings right. But Berkmens is a little low.

Yea I know he had a good year last year. But to put him over Waino (I know he didn't play last year, and is coming off of elbow surgery) and Garcia (Look at his last 2 seasons) is nuts IMO. I think he deserves to be 3rd or 4th, but not 2nd. Oh well. No big deal. They didn't overrate him. They underrated Garcia especially. Berkman had a HUGE season for us last year, but his 2009 and 2010 seasons weren't as good. Especially in the Average and HR department. Overall the ratings look pretty good though.

[DanH35]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

The first thing I'm going to do when I get the game is lower Lohse's ratings, no way he should be rated higher than Garcia.

[tabarnes19_SDS]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

shouldn't Jose Bautista have a longer contract than 1 year? its gonna suck seeing the cpu try and unload him in franchise again this year.
cant they not at the very least let us adjust the years in the contracts??

Do the contract trick pre-franchise...It still works. In roster management swap him for a player on free agent list 3 and then back and his contract will change.

[MetsFan16]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

Yeah I'm going to have to bump up Davis and Murph. There is no reason why they are rated so low. Maybe the injuries but that shouldn't impact a player's rating, except maybe Duraility.

[mr9inchesbpel]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

But they don't edit attributes.. I don't think so. 2Ks great at this, but the show lacks at actually updating the attributes.

No they do.

If you don't think they do then play on the default roster of the show and look up Justin Turner and then look up his attributes on the last roster.

Before the update I think he was the worse real player on the whole organization and then after the update he was an above average MLB bench player.

Also I think they made David Wright alot worse over the course of last season I think he had a full bar or close to a full bar at the start and then wound up by the end a good starter but nothing special.



I also think they lowered Adam Dunn to have 0 plate vision or something.

[econoodle]

Re: MLB 12 The Show Player Ratings Video - Top 9 Players Per Team

That Pirates roster is so depressing...

but but, AJ Burnett.


all kidding aside, he wins 17 games this year,
enjoy.