I would say yes, when you first start playing this game, All-Star feels quite challenging. However, right now I am playing on Superstar and working my way to HOF. I just started messing with the Defense Assist slider (under controller options). I had it at zero and put it up to 50, I must say it really helps you stay in front of your man. I don't know if this is for everyone, but it really does help. If I up that slider to 50, I may drop down the On Ball Defense slider for User. Would you mind giving that a shot when you play? See if you like the Defense Assist Slider at 50.