A couple of years ago, I would have said yes because I am a presentation geek. However, after my brother turned off the commentary to his Madden, I've found that most sports games are better with the commentary off. I mean, we're never going to get smooth commentary (and that includes 2kSports, who's baseball commentary is top notch). I'd rather listen to the sound of the game and have Josh Lewin* and Tom Grieve call my games in my head.