I played both, the PS3 looks much better this year. But, the frame rate was really bad for me. Most noticeable when hitting fouls. I liked the game play slightly better on the PS3, maybe because of the controller having a different feel while pitching. It was definitely easier to pitch on the PS3. The frame rate is a game killer for me on the PS3. As mentioned the xbox360 was sharper, but I feel the color was better on the PS3. I'll go with the PC version again this year. The mods will make the game look 100% better.