Yes, my apologies if that is confusing, I only put in blue the sliders I made changes to while playing on HOF. I would think the official roster should work fine, however custom rosters may work better since they have updated tendencies for all players (which is why my tendencies are all left on 50). Give it a try with default roster and see if it works. Are you on 360 or Ps3? Maybe somebody can suggest a good roster if you are in fact playing on 360.