[Jgainsey]

Quote: Originally Posted by jkeefeholmes

Hmm ok, when just a guy on first, I do the same, point to 2nd and he steals, does that make sense? I did misunderstand and thanks for clarifying it. I wonder why it works when just a guy on first? Oh well. Thanks!

It works because you're pressing L2.

If a runner isn't selected as you press L2, it becomes a "steal all" button. Meaning that all base runners will steal if you press L2. Though if you're doing this with only one runner on base, you may end up thinking you're doing it correctly.