Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

[Playmakers]

I took a break last year from the football rosters as most of you know. So this year I'm going to create teams based on the feedback of the Poll results and of course on the product that EA delivers for NCAA 13

For those who have used the rosters in the past you know I'm very detailed on the players.

This year I will allow the forum to decide what type of rosters to create for NCAA 13.

This roster file will again be for XBOX 360 USER's only (Sorry PS3 USER's)....if anyone is willing to help with these teams this year it would be much appreciated that way i can roughly 100+ teams as opposed to 50-60 teams like in years past.

[Gap Integrity]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

I wish they would bring bak the classic teams. It would be amazing to play with 98 Ohio State online.

[vaeath]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

I voted for the 2000-2009 one.

Will you be certain teams again? If so an all Virginia Tech team would be awesome!

[Playmakers]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

I voted for the 2000-2009 one.

Will you be certain teams again? If so an all Virginia Tech team would be awesome!

Yeah the All Decade Teams would probably be about 60 Total squads created and Virginia Tech would most likely be one of them for sure.

Remember All Decade Teams would only consist of players who played from 2000-2009

For example this is how a Virginia Tech All Decade team would look if the Poll results had more people who voted that way

The Best of the Best: The 2000's Virginia Tech All-Decade Team (I refuse to say aughts)

http://www.gobblercountry.com/2010/1/8/1230206/the-best-of-the-best-the-2000s

Now I personally would take Vick as the QB but that is just an example of the fan voting by Hokies fans for their team

[Playmakers]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

I wish they would bring bak the classic teams. It would be amazing to play with 98 Ohio State online.

The only problem i have with those teams is EA would rate them and to be honest your better off downloading classic rosters from forum members because EA does a terrible job with their rosters and don't really research the players or team.

Now if they included these teams (with old school uni's) and gave us the ability to edit the rosters ourselves that would be really nice. I could do some awesome editing and probably more schools completed sooner.

[carnalnirvana]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

i voted for the year teams, makes it easier for me since i am always conflicted when using the all time teams...

i like the more recent stars as opposed to the old timers....

either way should be awesome.

[jethrotull]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

Why not a 1993 roster set?

[Gap Integrity]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

EA's rosters are junk. It wouldn't be bad if you didn't watch alot of college football, but those of us who do know better. I wonder if Danny O'Brien makes it on Wisconsin's team? They spend little time on player detail, and they always miss on transfered players.
I spend as much time on my rosters as I do playing the game. But i'll be honest, I enjoy it. It's rewarding to do a team, have every detail correct. then play with the team. It's even better when you get people telling you your roster is great.

[schumj]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

As I have told you many times PM big fan! I personally would prefer the specific years. I have been thinking about undertaking either a project like that or all-90's decade. I started my 95 season rosters last year before my daughter was born and have had no time to complete once she arrived, but did find that anything prior to really 2001 had very little details on smaller teams and really any teams outside the top 20-30 schools.

I would love to see the 95 Huskers, 01 Canes, 95 Northwestern, 05 Texas, USC, 02 Ohio St, 93 or 99 FSU, 99 V-Tech, 97 or 98 Tennessee 96 Florida all battling for the NC. There are so many possibilities. I love your current work but prefer players I actually watched. Never been a big fan of the pre 80's players in files with current NFL players. Dean Steinkuhler was great but he wouldn't have a chance at his size to become a HOF going against 330 lb lineman. There are always exceptions but mostly I don't see it as realistic.

The decade teams are great too. Especially going with the 00's. There is plenty of info available and tons of great talents also. I would rather have the 90's mainly cause it was the era I grew up and became a huge fan of and actually think there is better talent available.

Whichever way you go though I look forward too as you have never dissapointed and always put so much work and detail into it. Looking forward. Hopefully their is better options for 13 to make it even better.

[JBCAROLINAKID]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

I would rather see teams from specific years rather than all-time teams. I kinda like seeing some of the lesser players make big plays for their team.

[Playmakers]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

WOW!

I didn't expect the Specific Year Team(s) to dominate the polls in this manner. I will monitor this thread right up to NFL draft weekend and if it becomes apparent that the Specific Year Team(s) is still running away with the polls then I start the research project In May in putting those teams together.

Example of Each Schools Best Year Team

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/495414-the-greatest-season-of-every-college-football-team

Now another thing i can do is replace the All-Decade team(s) from 2000-2009 with a All-Decade Team(s) from the 90's for each program similiar to what schumj suggested

If that becomes the case this would be a sample of how those teams would be created

The Rivalry's Top 10 College Football Programs of the 1990's: Part 1

http://www.offtackleempire.com/2009/1/19/727964/the-rivalry-s-top-10-colle

[Gap Integrity]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

yea i agree. Like year specific teams more. Imagine playing online with these. Man would that be fun for us college football junkies. 2002 OSU v.s. 1997 Michigan..... lets do it!

[xxSTEELCITYDxx]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

do you have theses for ps/3 if not are you able to get the rosters to me so I can make them for ps/3?

[tommycoa]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

Food for thought on your vote fellow voters. All-Decade teams from the 2000-09 era would work a lot better because of the way the game is made. It is quite a headache to get 95 Nebraska's offensive system to work just right.

Also. I think it would be cooler for the decade team as far as player match-ups. Take for instance an all decade team would give you the chance to pit better players against each other. For instance with a team like Oregon you could start either Joey Harrington or Dennis Dixon at quarterback. Gives room for a lot more variety.

Hopefully, 13 will have formation subs for the play now games. Just seems that Play Now plays a different game of football and the formation subs adds a lot to the game. Especially with running back and wide receiver rotation. Esp. WR.

[AttackAttack]

Re: Playmakers NCAA 13 Historic Team(s) Poll

Hey man if you wanna do a 1987 South Carolina team, I'll help you out.

They had such stars as Todd Ellis at qb. Sterling sharpe at wr. And Harold green at rb.

Ellis is pretty much unknown now. But he had a cannon for a arm. And he put up crazy numbers. Threw for just short of 10,000 yards.

http://www.dixiefriedsports.com/Gamecock_Hype.html