People have been saying this since '08. Go back a ton of pages in the NCAA Forum and look at complaints from NCAA 09 and 10, you will find the exact same complaints as the ones we are bringing up here. THERE IS A REASON why people can look at MLB The Show and say it looks the same, but it is taken in a positive sense, because that gameplay is SOLID. It PLAYS like BASEBALL *almost* FLAWLESSLY. However, people look at NCAA and say it looks the same in a negative sense because the same issues since 07 are still here and these issues severely affect the game of football. A cornerback backpedling to the sidelines every option play? A Linebacker with the blocking ability of Dikembe Mutumbo? Every player on the field being able to turn on a dime? NO CHANGES TO SPECIAL TEAMS AT ALL?
The basics of football are hardly represented in this game. That is why we "overreact".