Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

[msdm27]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

Sorry, just one more thing...

It bugs me that people act as if hardcore gamers was defined by whether you hang in forums or not and "casual" gamers is people that just buy the game and play it.... Guess what, people that don't read the forums and just buy the game to play it ARE NOT STOOPID! They at least know something about the nfl.

Do some people really think the "casual" gamer is gonna be ok when he's starts a CCM as his own player and after 2 years he wants to play as someone else only to find out his original player had to retire after being a 2 year pro? (That is something a casual gamer won't know until he finds out the shocking truth by the time it's too late because EA already has his money)

BTW, imo one of the best ways to help reduce this player edit mess would be to eliminate the DE position as a generic and just turn it into DE/OLB and then the drafting/fa signing/scheme logic wouldn't be so flawed... but hey, how could they possibly ever think of this?

[CatMan72]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Clarification

So if you are running a "franchise" through CC you can't edit any of the players in that "franchise"?

[BreaksoftheGame]

Last year was the first year I didn't buy Madden.....with the inability to play a "franchise" with edited league this will continue.

EA as a company continues to push me away from video games. Customization is key for me.

I would actually like to play more video games but with NCAA basketball not being made (nor the rosters fully editable, jumpshots, class etc....) I continue to find no reason to support EA sports games.

[Jd_Seven]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

I touched on this in my previous post in this thread, and have not found any information on slider editing in CC looking on. Is it possible? is it allowed in offline CC for my OWN custom sliders?

I just can't find any information regarding this, anyone got a heads up if this is in the same case with the roster editing?

[SeahawksFan89]

Can't imagine they will be able to patch player edit in time, so the best I can hope for is Madden 14.... Until then I'll stick with Madden 12, it may not have a fake twitter feed or Trey, but at least I can play my way with 32 team control and full player customisation.

Just feels like the dev team have gone all out for online and have sacrificed offline gamers in the process....

[Yeats]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

I usually spend more time editing than I do playing, so this news makes Madden 13 an automatic no-purchase for me. That said, I think I understand what they're trying to accomplish with CC. It sounds innovative. It's too bad editing was removed, but I can see how CC can and will appeal to the 95% of Madden gamers who have no interest in player editing, and who simply want to get on with playing the game.

This trend of developing games specifically with the online gamer in mind has been going on for years. I'm not surprised at all by any of this. And maybe that's why it doesn't bother me: I'm resigned to the fact this is the direction all games are headed.

[Herky]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

Going back to 2005 I remember how awesome the community has been here with player edits, creation, and various roster tweaks that were done almost monthly. I will have to say I will miss all the hard work people have done in the past on here. I created rosters in 2006 and 2007 in here for PS2 and although it was a lot of work, it was something that I enjoyed doing. Others did a great job with rosters over the years as well.

Last season I created around 55 free agents to fill the pool up with guys who were not in the game. I liked seeing Brett Favre in the FA pool, or having the ability to sign Randy Moss mid-season if I wanted. That may seem obsessive to some, but it made my Madden experience realistic and unique.

Like the poster above, I too spent a lot of time editing rosters. I wouldn't get my "real" franchise started until late September or early October because of the time I would put in to get the rosters where I wanted them.

[TreFacTor]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

WOW!

whose stupid *** idea was this? WTF makes them think Madden is a 1 player game???

ok hold, let me calm down.

what if i made my Franchise an online franchise. could we play a 2 player franchise that way even though we are on the same console?

im getting this for the 360 so couldnt we take advantage of the fact that u can sign in with 2 different profiles?

Both profiles will need the online pass and Live Gold subs. So you will buy one copy of Madden that has the online pass, and have to buy one additional online pass.

[RGiles36]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

Hey man I am assuming that you were at the Community events this year along with other game changers if so was the idea of no roster editing brought up by EA and if so what was the response by you guys ..just curious !!! If you were not a part of it then just ignore the question..You sound just as suprised as us..thanks!!

I went in February -- I couldn't make the event in May.

Roster editing wasn't brought up back then b/c so much of the mode was still "fluid"...as in they were still doing a lot of work to it. I don't think it dawned on any of us then that there would be no 'edit' player.

[ArghMuffinMan]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

I touched on this in my previous post in this thread, and have not found any information on slider editing in CC looking on. Is it possible? is it allowed in offline CC for my OWN custom sliders?

I just can't find any information regarding this, anyone got a heads up if this is in the same case with the roster editing?

Yes this has been confirmed a few times now. The lack of editing affects the control of players and team control, not the fundamental game play.

[djordan]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

The problem is, take the number of people on this forum who are upset by it and let's assume everyone who voted on that CC most disappointment poll was at least somewhat upset by this and divide that 351 by even just the first week sales of Madden 12... 351/1,400,000... 0.03%

If you guys really want to make your voices heard, you're going to need to do a lot more than complain (and promptly get blocked) on Twitter. It's going to take letting other Madden players who DON'T frequent sites like this or aren't chomping at the bit for any E3 info about the game know about what's been left out. If it's really as big of an issue to the community outside of this über-serious demographic then the cause to get editing in will gain momentum. But really, gotta be more creative and professional about it than whiney Twitter posts (yes, I realize I'm generalizing and am sure some people have made mild-mannered and respectful comments but I'm afraid at this point even those get lost in the shuffle due to the "hate tweets" they are surely getting)

I would suggest someone sending an email to IGN, gamespot, or any other major videogame website. They have more traffic coming to their website than OS by far.

[tical2399]

I was already out when they said in NCAA draft class import. This is just more of a kick to the face for those who used to love this series. Oh well, I'll keep my 60 bones. Borderlands 2 (PC) here I come.

[wheelman990]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

I would suggest someone sending an email to IGN, gamespot, or any other major videogame website. They have more traffic coming to their website than OS by far.

I am hopeful the sim standard and all other youtube video makers get on this too. This is a feature that can't be lost! It took From Madden 06-12 to finally complete the editing feature like we had previous generation with 2k5!!

This announcement really made me stop and look at all the things we still don't have with Madden that we had last generation. Custom camera's,stadium music, and celebrations were some of them. Hard to believe that other then online features(wasn't popular back then) last generation had more features in their game. This is EA's 8th xbox 360 release!

[crenk]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

why couldnt they have just kept a separate "franchise mode" like they have had every other year in addition to CC etc, to keep the hundreds of thousands of loyal madden customers who play exclusively offline franchise happy

[cjonesfan921]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Roster Editing Issue Rears Its Ugly Head

Thankfully not a big issue for me. Just hope the game play is there.