I think that's fair, I'm not at all keen on the tape to tape passes either, and really hope this is just an indication of a work in progress early build, and hearing QB mention EAC is aware of the pass reception slider issues, and really how could they not be with the game having been out in the wild for almost a full cycle now. Leads me to believe it'll either be adjusted, or that may be once again one element of the game we'll be disappointed it.
It's never going to be 100% sim. Once one realizes that as fact and just enjoys it for what it is, it goes down a bit easier I suppose? I dunno.
There's things about the game that bug me, it's far from perfect as I've said time and time again, but at the end of the day, I have fun playing it and I get a challenge out of Superstar, which is I think what's important, at least for me tending to be a bit more forgiving than certain people.