Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

[StreetCarp]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

IMO, it should go like this:

Rodgers 98
Brady 97
Brees 97
Stafford 95
E. Manning 94
P. Manning 93
Romo 92
Roethlisberger 91
Ryan 88
Rivers 87

[shavane]

I am a Eaglews fan and Vick is right where he needs to be I would argue that Cam should be on this list and Brees should be number 1. I may be wrong here but didn't he break a single season passing record thats stood for 25 years.

[sportjames23]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

Eli vastly overrated same for Ben. No way either of these two are better than Phillip Rivers.

4 rings vs 0.

*runs out the room*

[riggs6taters]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

Eli Manning a 97?? Dude is closer to 77. Wow so is every player on the defense 99s and I don't even want to know what Hicks and Cruz will be...good gosh.

Another obvious and downright clown rating is Arrestedberger, how can you even think he is a 95?

Romo is underrated if anything, all he did was have MVP numbers and add to his 97 career QB rating.

Ben - 92 QB rating for career
Eli - 82 QB rating for career (lol)

[k2thaz]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

Eli Manning a 97?? Dude is closer to 77. Wow so is every player on the defense 99s and I don't even want to know what Hicks and Cruz will be...good gosh.

Another obvious and downright clown rating is Arrestedberger, how can you even think he is a 95?

Romo is underrated if anything, all he did was have MVP numbers and add to his 97 career QB rating.

Ben - 92 QB rating for career
Eli - 82 QB rating for career (lol)

whatever drugs ur on I want some if you think Romo is underrated. Obviously a cowboy fan.

[riggs6taters]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

whatever drugs ur on I want some if you think Romo is underrated. Obviously a cowboy fan.

Care to give reasons/facts or just make erroneous claims and jokes?

The 97 QB rating is a fact, the playoff wins are part of the TEAM. Hence the reason a terrible QB like Eli can have 2 rings.

[eds133]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

Wish they would've broken down the ratings more.. like their throw power and accuracy and stuff. I wonder if Big Ben is that high because of the new physical rating and him fitting his scheme...I want to see how their ratings break down though.. i bet that could shed some light on how their ratings are what they are.

[StrawHat Patriot]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

Eli Manning a 97?? Dude is closer to 77. Wow so is every player on the defense 99s and I don't even want to know what Hicks and Cruz will be...good gosh.

Another obvious and downright clown rating is Arrestedberger, how can you even think he is a 95?

Romo is underrated if anything, all he did was have MVP numbers and add to his 97 career QB rating.

Ben - 92 QB rating for career
Eli - 82 QB rating for career (lol)

That's the problem with the ratings in general. Is it based on last year, their whole career, or next season?

[43M]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

IMO, it should go like this:

Rodgers 98
Brady 97
Brees 97
Stafford 95
E. Manning 94
P. Manning 93
Romo 92
Roethlisberger 91
Ryan 88
Rivers 87

Stafford should not be a 95 based on one season where all he did most of the year was throw the ball up to an uncoverable WR.

Staffod led the league in bad decision percentage and was one had alot of bad throws to Megatron that he got bailed out on.

Put him at 90 and I can agree with those ratings.

[43M]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

Eli vastly overrated same for Ben. No way either of these two are better than Phillip Rivers.

If Ben and Eli are overrated, what does that make the guy who only puts up big stats against poor defenses and chokes when the team needs him the most.

Ill take the two clutch winners over the stat monster any day.

[StrawHat Patriot]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

If you're basing it off last season and going in to this year (in terms of skill set, stats, circumstances, and the production with their talent):

Aaron Rodgers 89
Tom Brady 87
Drew Brees 85
Eli Manning 85
Tony Romo 85
Phillip Rivers 84
Ben Roethlisberger 83
Michael Vick 82
Matthew Stafford 82

Peyton Manning 82

For their careers:

Tom Brady 95
Peyton Manning 95

Aaron Rodgers 86
Drew Brees 85


Tony Romo 83
Phillip Rivers 83
Ben Roethlisberger 81
Eli Manning 81
Matthew Stafford 80
Michael Vick 77

[btemp]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

If you're basing it off last season and going in to this year (in terms of skill set, stats, circumstances, and the production with their talent):

Aaron Rodgers 89
Tom Brady 87
Drew Brees 85
Eli Manning 85
Tony Romo 85
Phillip Rivers 84
Ben Roethlisberger 83
Michael Vick 82
Matthew Stafford 82

Peyton Manning 82

For their careers:

Tom Brady 95
Peyton Manning 95

Aaron Rodgers 86
Drew Brees 85

Eli Manning 81
Tony Romo 83
Phillip Rivers 83
Ben Roethlisberger 81
Matthew Stafford 80
Michael Vick 77

I'd scale it up a little, maybe Rodgers at 95, but overall I agree.

The irony is that if you were to spread the ratings out a lot more, and remove so many players from the 90+ range, players would be more unique. A big reason players currently aren't is because so many of them are clustered around the same point range resulting in the same play.

[bspang2]

Tony Romo is a 90 Overall???? BASED ON WHAT? Tony Romo has not proven himself as a winner or a clutch QB for years and has only reached the playoffs twice and has never made it past the first round of the playoffs.

[StrawHat Patriot]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

Tony Romo is a 90 Overall???? BASED ON WHAT? Tony Romo has not proven himself as a winner or a clutch QB for years and has only reached the playoffs twice and has never made it past the first round of the playoffs.

Tony Romo is a 90 overall based on his stats because he passed for more touchdowns than Eli Manning, threw less picks than Drew Brees, Eli Manning, and Tom Brady, his completion percentage is higher than Tom Brady and Eli Manning, He is in the top 5 all-time for career passer rating, and was one of the league leaders in 4th Quarter Passer Rating.

Romo is better than Eli, the only reason why Tony's teams don't make it that far is because they never unite like Eli's Giants teams do. The cowboys as a TEAM seem to never rise up and play their best when they need to. Look at Week 17 against the Giants, that game was close at one point, but the Cowboys defense couldn't step up. Tony is also unlucky as even Giants fans mention that Eli can at times throw off his back foot and won't get picked off because his receivers will actually make a play.

Tony Romo freaking lost a game that he led would should have been the game winning drive if not for his own coach icing his OWN kicker.

[goravens2052]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

Based on? Cutler's HIGHEST QB rating is 3 points lower than Romo's LOWEST QB rating. Romo is better in just about every category.

Way to shorten my post as I explained why. The Bears were on their way to the playoffs and were close to locking up a playoff spot before Jay Cutler got injured. If Cutler didn't get injured, they would have been in the playoffs no doubt. Romo better than Cutler? Come talk to me when Romo becomes a clutch player and doesn't fail under pressure.