Never been one to care too much on ratings, but Brees with a deep ball accuracy of 84 compared to RG3 who is higher is ridiculous when stats show Brees has been one of the best at it over the last few years
Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
Collapse
Recommended Videos
Collapse
X
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
Never been one to care too much on ratings, but Brees with a deep ball accuracy of 84 compared to RG3 who is higher is ridiculous when stats show Brees has been one of the best at it over the last few yearsSaints, LSU, Seminoles, Pelicans, Marlins, Lightning -
Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
I like looking at the Broncos rookie QB Brock Os. Becuase he is only a 69 but a deep throw accuracy of 83 and a throw power of 96, I looked and saw his awareness at 39 lol. So to drop a QB down they just messed with his awareness, which means I could use him and still be leathal if Manning goes down lol. O this is going to be great being able to launch it deep to DT lol.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
Ratings have been, for the most part, been updated on weekly basis. There will probably even be one on or near release day.The problem with waiting until the roookies "prove" they deserve that is that people who play with those teams that are expecting them to be good, with no edits, we would have to wait until donny releases the new update through the mid-end of the season which by then I would already be deep into my franchise.
But that is my opinion on why it is done that way.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
Looking at all the ratings, now that I am home, and one must say that EA has moved away from stretched out ratings. 9 players in the 90's isnt the worst thing in the world (I would like between 5 and 7), but 27 QBs are 80 or higher and 43 with a 75 or higher. That is like saying 43 QBs in the league are better than average. How do your really separate between teams and players. .Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
Oh don't worry, it will only get worse when the game comes out. Besides, I think the more it gets brought up the more it will show EA how important it is to allow users to edit ratings.Originally posted by EaglesFan1825Thanks for bringing it up...for the millionth time.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
Out of the gate this is lame. Here are the QB's he has Throwing power wise equal to or having higher throwing power than Flacco.
Equal
RGIII
Derrick Anderson
Jerrod Johnson
Ryan Periloux
Tarvaris Jackson
Jake Locker
Greater Than
Aaron Rogers
Tom Brady
Josh Freeman
Matthew Stafford
Michael Vick
Cam Newton
Jay Cutler
John Skelton
Ryan Mallett
Brock Osweiler
How is all of this measured and calculated? What sources are being used to determine arm strength?
I have my hunch as to why Flacco's lower than those other guys, especially with the speed WR's we have this year.
Get the throwing power up and take the speed and trucking down.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
I'm sorry, I know Brandon Weeden hasn't played a real NFL game yet and all, but COMON, he should not be rated lower than Colt McCoy!!! That's ridiculous, I don't mind them being close, but if Colt McCoy is a 75 then Weeden should be a 77 or higher imo. Not saying he should be a 77, just saying McCoy is not better than Brandon Weeden, end of story.
How many of you would play an online game with Colt McCoy starting for the Browns instead of Brandon Weeden, honestly? (silence)Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
as far as ratings distribution
the NFL had a 9-7 team win the super bowl
the previous year a 10-6 6th place team won the super bowl
the 49ers were a loser team before last year and turned it around and went 13-3
how do you separate them when a 9-7 team can beat a 15-1 team, but then lose to a 5-11 team twice?Last edited by Edi286; 08-03-2012, 11:38 AM.Comment
-
I just think RGIII and Luck are rated just a little to high. Not by much but would've rather seen them knocked down 2-3 overall points each.
Just hope progression is good this year because in the past both would be 90+ by next year.Texas A&M Aggies
Denver Broncos
Colorado Avalanche
Colorado RockiesComment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
Sliders my good man, that's exactly what this thread is about...http://www.operationsports.com/forum...games-ccm.htmlLooking at all the ratings, now that I am home, and one must say that EA has moved away from stretched out ratings. 9 players in the 90's isnt the worst thing in the world (I would like between 5 and 7), but 27 QBs are 80 or higher and 43 with a 75 or higher. That is like saying 43 QBs in the league are better than average. How do your really separate between teams and players. .The Impact of User vs User Sliders In CFM 5.0*
http://www.operationsports.com/forum...post2047473988Comment
-
Man they shafted my man Vick with the speed rating again he's atleast a 93...smh. and btw Vick has THE strongest arm in the league. point. blank.
Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
I understand sliders help (I use them), but they shouldn't have to be used to make players ratings differentiated. They should be used to make the game easier or harder if I am playing as a specific team.Sliders my good man, that's exactly what this thread is about...http://www.operationsports.com/forum...games-ccm.html
I should be able to play a game on all-pro or even pro(the default setting) and be able to tell the difference between a Pro-Bowl QB, Mid Level QB, and a back-up.
But that is another topic for another thread.Comment
-
I think agility ratings for the top QBs should be high, because after few yrs in the franchise mode, most QBs rated in the 90s, except for top 3, are going to drop into the 80s. This does not happen in real life!! After 2 yrs or so in franchise mode you'll see Vick, Mannings drop by 5-8 in overall ratings.Comment
-
Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings
Not really true, last year after about 3 seasons Brees/Brady/Peyton only dropped maybe 1 or 2 points. Peyton Manning is understandable given his age if he drops more thoI think agility ratings for the top QBs should be high, because after few yrs in the franchise mode, most QBs rated in the 90s, except for top 3, are going to drop into the 80s. This does not happen in real life!! After 2 yrs or so in franchise mode you'll see Vick, Mannings drop by 5-8 in overall ratings.Saints, LSU, Seminoles, Pelicans, Marlins, LightningComment

Comment