Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

[Shiny Cony]

Makes me laugh when i see RGIII rated higher than tim tebow.

[DNMHIII]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

Makes me laugh when i see RGIII rated higher than tim tebow.

Do you watch college football?

[N51_rob]

Makes me laugh when i see RGIII rated higher than tim tebow.

Because a career 47.3 completion percentage makes Tebow a great QB.

Tebow's QBR puts him ahead of Curtis Painter and Blaine Gabbert.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

[dingleberryfinn]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

Rusty Smith rated higher than Josh Portis?
wtf!?


lmao

[Candyman5]

It pays to read the first post in full;

You're welcome.

I seen that before but I didn't notice the document popping up when I clicked on it and it directed me to that page of 4 ratings listed. So yes I did read the first post.....-_-

[KingV2k3]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

So I guess it safe to say that John Parker Wilson throws like a girl, with a deep ball accuracy of 47.

Yup...absolutely ridiculous...

Dude might not be more than a taxi squad QB, but I'm sure he can "make all (or most) of the NFL throws" or he wouldn't still be in the league...

Has anyone figured out how accuracy works in Madden?

I always thought it should be based on aiming at a particular point, whether that be the receiver or a spot on the field and the rating dictating how accurate the player is at hitting that mark. Also with other variables like pressure and weather modifying the rating according to AWR and DPP. However I doubt that's how accuracy works in Madden and I would be interested to know how others think it actually does.

Honestly I have no clue. I think the overall accuracy matters more than deep, mid and short accuracy.

I had a QB who had a 74 overall accuracy and an 88 deep accuracy yet he still overthrew deep balls all the time and was generally inaccurate on the whole.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

My THEORY is that the overall accuracy combines with the short, medium and deep accuracy ratings to determine success...

For example:

Romo's overall ACC is 88

Short is 90

Medium is 84

Deep is 90

When "averaging" the overall with the S/M/D his ratings "adjust" to:

88+90 divided by 2 = 89 (short)

88+84 divided by 2 = 86 (medium)

88+90 divided by 2 = 89 (deep)

It might make "too much sense", but that's the way I BELIEVE it was meant to work / works...

As far as the deep accuracy issues N51_Rob describes:

I believe in the past 2-3 iterations of the game, deep ball completion is really a product of "pinpoint pressure" on the button and the WR having position or a step on the defender...as well as when in the route you release the ball...

It was intended to make it tougher (fine by me), but really ended up make it kind of "arbitrary"...

I went from not being able to hit the broad side of a barn (deep) with 'Skins Crompton, (low overall ACC / nice deep ball rating) by focusing on the above...

I am curious to see if we will be able to find a roster workaround for the game. With NBA Live 10 rosters we were able to sneak rosters from one file to the next through USB saves by copying and pasting the roster data but keeping the profile name the same. I wonder if we edited the rosters but then copied the roster data over to an official EA roster file if we would be able to cheat the system and do this? Maybe EA has blocked this or it's not possible in Madden but I'd like to see if it's possible.

I wasn't aware of this for LIVE, so if you know how to make this happen, you're going to be MVP of this year's rosters, Sir!

PLEASE keep us posted!!!

[gatek99]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

how are these the complete ratings? What are the other accuracy ratings for these guys?

[Riddler]

Not the stretched out ratings I was hoping for. No way Eli and Roethlisberger should be that close to Brees, Brady and Rodgers. There should be at least a 5 point gap between the elite 3 and the rest. Eli and Ben are good QBs that play great in the clutch but they are not consistent enough to warrant 97 and 95 ratings. Just because they won multiple SBs shouldn't automatically make them have better accuracy than they really do.

And they made RG3 an absolute BEAST! 97 THP and the fifth highest deep accuracy in the game at 88. Not to mention 93 SPD. He will be abused online.

Don't get me wrong, I think RG3 will be legit in real life but those ratings are a bit high and would make him a top 5 QB right now if you take out AWR which is meaningless. And don't understand why his DAC is so much higher than Cam's (75 DAC) who has actually proved good deep accuracy at the NFL level. He's also higher than Vick (84 DAC) who pretty much only throws deep strikes to Desean.

It's nice that they're releasing the full ratings before the game releases though.

So basically you have no idea what you're talking about? Got it.

[codyj123_321]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

Tebow rated higher than Brady Quinn makes me wanna absolutely throw up. Quinn is a far better passer than Tebow and the fact that Quinn never got his chance in Denver cause the fans wanted Tebow. He jumped into the starting role from the fans like it's a popularity contest. I really hope Quinn gets a fair chance one of these days. He hasn't since he got to the NFL, besides when he started 9 games or so for he Browns. That team was absolutely horrible and despite that Quinn didn't put up amazing numbers, but he did good considering who he had on that team.

[bmj2k7]

Guess Jake Locker will be getting a boost or Hasselback taking a decrease since it looks like Locker will win the starting job in TEN, its now Lockers job to lose. I guess bc there similar passing, Lockers mobility and huge arm and there similar decision making gave him the edge

[1D4ever]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

Tebow rated higher than Brady Quinn makes me wanna absolutely throw up. Quinn is a far better passer than Tebow and the fact that Quinn never got his chance in Denver cause the fans wanted Tebow. He jumped into the starting role from the fans like it's a popularity contest. I really hope Quinn gets a fair chance one of these days. He hasn't since he got to the NFL, besides when he started 9 games or so for he Browns. That team was absolutely horrible and despite that Quinn didn't put up amazing numbers, but he did good considering who he had on that team.

um no...As a Raiders fan I can't stand Tebow I think he is one of the most overrated players in sometime. Brady Quinn can't tie his shoes, Brady Quin can't tie any one shoes. Quinn is so bad I still think JaMarcus Russell is better. Tebow accomplished more in two game than Quinn has his whole career, Not that He won those game anymore's than the defense or Willis but I don't think Quinn could have managed those games good enough to win.

[Jono078]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

Apparently 68 of the 113 Quarterbacks throw on the run equally the same.

Not sure if anyone has said that yet, but that's the big thing I noticed.

I can't believe no one has commented on this one yet!

I thought this would have sent the community into a rage.

[Dj_MyTime]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

Newton wasn't even close to Luck in college. In the nfl newton had a very good rookie year... But he threw a ton of picks.

Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk 2

Where do people get this "tons of picks" stuff from. He only threw 17 in comparison to his 21 passing TD's.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/player/stats/_/id/13994/cam-newton

Meanwhile QB's like Philip Rivers threw 20 (87 DAC) 92 ovr http://search.espn.go.com/philip-rivers/, Eli Manning threw 16 (96 DAC) 97 ovr, http://search.espn.go.com/eli-manning/.

So when compared to "elite type QB's" he stacks up fairly similary, so why the drop in accuracy across the board when in M 12 he finished the season with an 85 DAC rating iirc. 89 SAC, 86 MAC, 75 DAC....it just doesn't make sense when you compare his season to QB's who finished with similar statistics.

Then for players who don't even have NFL snaps under their belts to be as INFLATED as they are, there's no excuse. The ONLY reason RGIII is as hyped as he is, is because Newton set a new perception of black, mobile, spread QB's, simple as that. If Newton had stunk it up RGIII would've been drafted mid-late 1st, and Weeden would've been the first QB after Luck.

[XplosiveRunna26]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

Honestly it doesn't seem to matter how FAST these QB's run....the D-Line somehow outruns them and catches them anyways...smh. It's so frustrating seeing vick get hawked by a 6'6 350lb lineman behind the line of scrimmaged.

[Dj_MyTime]

Re: Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Complete QB Ratings

Honestly it doesn't seem to matter how FAST these QB's run....the D-Line somehow outruns them and catches them anyways...smh. It's so frustrating seeing vick get hawked by a 6'6 350lb lineman behind the line of scrimmaged.

That's what the "speed threshold" of 15 has helped eliminate. It's default is 35 points higher at 50, which means that there is less of a Madden difference between slower and faster players which is why that happens as often as it does.