NCAA Football 14 Sideline Reporter - Jemele Hill, Shannon Spake or Shelley Smith?

[kennyacid]

If you don't like someone fine, to each his own but all the name calling and disrespect is kinda childish

[calbrs04]

No consideration for Jenn Brown?

I second Jen Brown, if not then Wendy Nix.

[tbook24]

personally josina anderson is the right pick but i would take jemele hill out of these 3

[HouseOfBalloons]

Jenn Brown will get it without a doubt

[radney]

Shannon Spake is mostly known from her NASCAR coverage.

[AUChase]

I second that. He may have been good 15 years ago. Not anymore.

Sent from my 1983 Motorola DynaTAC mobile phone

Musburger hasn't missed a lick. He's still solid. I don't think you can ask for a better front man than him, Nessler, or Ron Franklin (back a few years ago). I think it would be cool, since ABC sports and ESPN are one in the same, to get a Musburger/Herbstreit and Nessler/Blackledge combo for different games.


Ignorant would be a better way to describe Hill, rather than idiotic, but when you're a professional in the sports world, you're open to any and all criticism. While I think Erin Andrews is a solid sideline reporter, I also find her to be a little over rated. I would still rather see Samantha Steele.

Sent from my Desire HD

[misterkrabz]

In this day and age do we really need a female (or any) sideline reporter? I mean seriously whose idea was it anyway? I've never seen a cuy away to a sideline reporter where it left me thinking, "gee I didn't know that" or "that was really good information".

[AUChase]

If we were electing male sideline reporters, Rinaldi is at the top of my list.

Will it really matter who they pick ? It's not like we will be seeing them much, anyways and if we did, people would start a thread griping about too many cut scenes interrupting their "button mashing" style game. People want authenticity, yet gripe when we get it (studio updates this year).

Sent from my Desire HD

[MattUM2]

Re: NCAA Football 14 Sideline Reporter - Jemele Hill, Shannon Spake or Shelley Smith?

Wait people actually like Jemille Hill?

She is awful

[Jeff George]

Re: NCAA Football 14 Sideline Reporter - Jemele Hill, Shannon Spake or Shelley Smith?

It's going to be Sam Steele or Jenn Brown. Not hard to market a young blonde for a game sold to college-age and older men.

[shhhonuff]

Jemelle Hill is the worst so anybody except her

[cparrish]

Re: NCAA Football 14 Sideline Reporter - Jemele Hill, Shannon Spake or Shelley Smith?

Anyone but Jemele Hill.

THIS!!!







10 char

[SkillzKillz719]

START UP THE HYPE MACHINEEEEEEEE! lol

[HitThatRowdy96]

Jenn Brown or Samantha Steele, though Holly Rowe, Wendy Nix, or Tom Rinaldi would be good (even if Rinaldi is more of a feature story/human interest type reporter from what I've seen). Of the three there, Smith has the most experience and does some good work; the few times I've seen Spake do something other than racing, she was okay; and Hill is honestly better as a columnist than a reporter and is better suited for shows like ATH and First Take as opposed to sideline reports.

That said, it would be an interesting twist to have nobody on the sideline.

[Adibesee]

Unless they improve the actual quality what is the point of having a sideline reporter. My choice is they have an actual half-time and post game show and skip the side line drivel.

20 years of this game and we cant get that level of basic immersion. SMH