Tough choice... Madden or NHL

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ChiTownKid
    MVP
    • Oct 2002
    • 1002

    #1

    Tough choice... Madden or NHL

    Money is real tight this time around, and it looks like I'll have to actually choose between the two, rather than buy both, which is what I've done for years.

    I'm leaning toward NHL, but fear I might get jumpy since Madden comes out two weeks before NHL.

    Thoughts? Opinions?




    Flames?
    107
    Madden
    0%
    8
    NHL
    0%
    85
    cake
    0%
    14
    im on ur pitch tacklin ur d00dz
  • I3RIS3H
    Pro
    • Jun 2011
    • 640

    #2
    Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

    Which is your preferred sport? That could possibly help. Also look at the improvements to each game from last year that you may like and compare.
    NHL: Chicago Blackhawks
    NFL: Kansas City Chiefs
    MLB: Kansas City Royals
    NCAA: Kansas Jayhawks

    Comment

    • TjJunior
      Rookie
      • Jun 2012
      • 274

      #3
      Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

      Originally posted by ChiTownKid
      Money is real tight this time around, and it looks like I'll have to actually choose between the two, rather than buy both, which is what I've done for years.

      I'm leaning toward NHL, but fear I might get jumpy since Madden comes out two weeks before NHL.

      Thoughts? Opinions?




      Flames?
      I would get NHL first. Madden is popular and will be on sale much sooner than NHL will be. Wait for Black Friday, EA always lets the football titles go on sale pretty fast. NCAA is already about 30-40 bucks.

      Comment

      • Broncos86
        Orange and Blue!
        • May 2009
        • 5505

        #4
        Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

        If I absolutely had to choose, I'd say NHL 13. Here's why:

        1) Madden 13 is still at the point of "work in progress." The Infinity Engine is still half-baked, so you're not going to see the final results until next year.

        2) Everything Madden is trumpeting, NHL is saying "I'm doing it better." Physics? Presentation? Career mode? Check, check, check.

        3) Don't be a Cake-eater.
        Last edited by Broncos86; 08-10-2012, 11:04 AM.

        Comment

        • Vikes1
          Proctor, MN. Go Rails!
          • May 2008
          • 4102

          #5
          Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

          Originally posted by I3RIS3H
          Which is your preferred sport? That could possibly help. Also look at the improvements to each game from last year that you may like and compare.
          This imo is solid advice.

          My own personal gut feelings are though...I've always gotten just more gaming satisfaction from playing NHL over Madden.
          1969 NFL Champions

          Comment

          • Segagendude
            Banned
            • Aug 2008
            • 7940

            #6
            Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

            I love football, yet I'm looking to get NHL 13.

            As much as I like the improvements made in Madden, the ones made in NHL seem far superior. The last video posted, "presentation blog", really made my choice that much easier...

            Comment

            • Dispatch
              MVP
              • Jan 2006
              • 2339

              #7
              Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

              I would go with NHL. Madden gets stale after a while in my opinion. NHL seems to be the more polished game this year.

              Like everyone else said, Maddens more likely to go on sale. You could also just wait for the demos and reviews if you don't mind waiting.

              Comment

              • geisterhome
                MVP
                • Sep 2011
                • 2101

                #8
                Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

                did you ask the same question in the madden forum?

                only that way you will get an unbiased result
                Spending time with Jesus!

                -Glad to be an Operation Sports Member!-

                Comment

                • CRMosier_LM
                  Banned
                  • Jul 2009
                  • 2061

                  #9
                  It depends. Game play may be better in NHL... Career mode much better in.Madden imo

                  Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk 2

                  Comment

                  • Broncos86
                    Orange and Blue!
                    • May 2009
                    • 5505

                    #10
                    Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

                    Originally posted by CRMosier_LM
                    It depends. Game play may be better in NHL... Career mode much better in.Madden imo

                    Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk 2
                    Since I haven't played either game, I cannot say for sure, but it looks to me that NHL 13's CCM is beyond Madden's CCM. 750 players per league, multiple roles played on each team. Play with multiple people on one team. Multiple camera angles per game. Both tout improved CPU signing/trade logic.

                    In recent years, NHL's roster management and player development has rocked Madden's. I know Madden is changing that, but it remains to be seen. In the past, I've been able to take NHL Be a GM mode further than Madden's franchise mode.

                    Comment

                    • MizzouRah
                      All Star
                      • Jul 2002
                      • 8548

                      #11
                      Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

                      Madden has been horrible since the 360 and ps3 came out, my opinion of course.

                      Comment

                      • Keirik
                        MVP
                        • Mar 2003
                        • 3770

                        #12
                        Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

                        You could ask this in the ,Madden forum and get that preferred, so take everything for what it's worth. However, you're in a position that both come out weeks apart so why not wait a few weeks then and read about which has less problems?

                        For me, I get Madden every year and play it a handful of times. I get NHL and play it a ton.
                        Yankees, Manchester United, Chicago Bears, New York Rangers

                        Comment

                        • Gagnon39
                          Windy City Sports Fan
                          • Mar 2003
                          • 8544

                          #13
                          Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

                          The title of this thread does not include an accurate question/statement. It is not a tough choice, at all. NHL. Unless you really like football games where it looks like all the players have a corn cob stuck up their rear ends when they run.
                          All the Way, Again: A Chicago Cubs Franchise

                          Streaming on Twitch
                          https://www.twitch.tv/gagnon39

                          Comment

                          • Vikes1
                            Proctor, MN. Go Rails!
                            • May 2008
                            • 4102

                            #14
                            Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

                            Originally posted by Gagnon39
                            The title of this thread does not include an accurate question/statement. It is not a tough choice, at all. NHL. Unless you really like football games where it looks like all the players have a corn cob stuck up their rear ends when they run.
                            Have to agree, Gagnon.

                            Standing still [screen shots] Madden looks great. But once the game is in motion...not so great. Imo...it'd help a lot if one day they could get rid of the zig-zag running.
                            1969 NFL Champions

                            Comment

                            • Gagnon39
                              Windy City Sports Fan
                              • Mar 2003
                              • 8544

                              #15
                              Re: Tough choice... Madden or NHL

                              Originally posted by Vikes1
                              Have to agree, Gagnon.

                              Standing still [screen shots] Madden looks great. But once the game is in motion...not so great. Imo...it'd help a lot if one day they could get rid of the zig-zag running.
                              Agreed. Its funny because at least to me it seems like the animations and flow of the game was better on the original Xbox.

                              I'm really hoping with the leap to the new Xbox in the next year or two EA Canada is smart enough to realize what a good core game they have with NHL. The last thing I would want to see is them start over from scratch and rebuild the entire game, which is what happened with Madden.
                              All the Way, Again: A Chicago Cubs Franchise

                              Streaming on Twitch
                              https://www.twitch.tv/gagnon39

                              Comment

                              Working...