Your statement was that "nothing" about the game was real. The game certainly has some realistic aspects to it. What about the graphics remotely compare to a cartoon? NCAA's graphics this year are much worse. The physics while not perfect are most definitely a step in the right direction and will provide for some entertaining games. The audio sounds excellent... I don't see the cheat logic you are referring to this year, like I have in years past. Last year, that was a valid argument.
This is a video game, It is important to remember that, but this game feels much more realistic than dare I say it... 2k8 or 2k5
This title is headed in the right direction... towards simulation. That is all I can ask. As long as it is moving forward, I have nothing to complain about