Good stats, though we are talking about the top 5 secondaries in
Madden. A game that punishes Carlos Rogers' and Tarell Brown's 88 and 87 speed ratings, and doesn't favor their 60 and 65 catch ratings. Fortunately for Rogers he has high ratings in awareness (89) and press coverage (93) that benefit his virtual self, but Brown's press coverage (70) doesn't help his case for being particularly useful in Madden.
You may dislike the Bengals and Taylor Mays, but Cincinnati is deeper than the 49ers at cornerback and Mays' speed and hit power do overpower him and make him useful in Madden. If we were talking about real life this conversation would be much different, but it is Madden after all.