NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ImaGamer_OS
    Future EA Game Changer
    • Apr 2012
    • 523

    #1

    NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

    NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

    Andrew Luck, Robert Griffin III, Russell Wilson or Ryan Tannehill?

    Poll your nomination and post your reasoning.

    p.s. Apologies Cleveland fans, forgot all about Weeden. If a moderator can edit the polling options as well the poll/thread title (add 'better') it would be appreciated.
    132
    Andrew Luck - Indianapolis Colts
    0%
    48
    Robert Griffin III - Washington Redskins
    0%
    51
    Russell Wilson - Seattle Seahawks
    0%
    29
    Ryan Tannehill - Miami Dolphins
    0%
    3
    Branden Weeden - Cleveland Browns
    0%
    1
    Other
    0%
    0
    Support: Indianapolis Colts - LA Lakers - Chelsea FC - Ferrari F1
  • iAM-IncReDiBLe-
    Next Miami Great
    • Dec 2008
    • 4285

    #2
    Wilson is on the best team so ima go with him. Followed by Luck.

    Comment

    • Redskinsfan26
      Pro
      • Jul 2009
      • 624

      #3
      RG3 has a lot of weapons, but does have a poor O line. I think he and Luck will have the pretty equal seasons
      REDSKINS & WIZARDS

      Comment

      • ImaGamer_OS
        Future EA Game Changer
        • Apr 2012
        • 523

        #4
        Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

        This will be close. I think RGIII may have the edge in a better situation than my boy Andrew Luck. Both will leave this class for dead short and long term.
        Support: Indianapolis Colts - LA Lakers - Chelsea FC - Ferrari F1

        Comment

        • SPTO
          binging
          • Feb 2003
          • 68046

          #5
          Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

          Call me skeptical but I don't think lightning will strike twice for Indy in getting a true franchise QB for the 2nd straight time so i'm going with RGIII long term but I think Russell Wilson has a shot at being the Ken O'Brien of this QB class in that he has a solid if not unspectacular career and goes to the playoffs a few times.

          I know I know, i'm on the damn bandwagon with this kid but that's my feeling.
          Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club

          "Baseball is the most important thing that doesn't matter at all" - Robert B. Parker

          Comment

          • wwharton
            *ll St*r
            • Aug 2002
            • 26949

            #6
            Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

            Depends on what "better" means. Last year all the hype was around Newton (and rightfully so) while Dalton lead a team in a tougher division to the playoffs with his prime target also being a rookie.

            That didn't cause too much conversation bc of the insane numbers Newton put up but if we assume that's not going to happen again, which is the better way to look at it?

            I think RG3 will play very well and lead the Skins to a good record (probably 2nd to Seattle of these guys but the two teams will be close). But I think Luck will have the best stats bc his team will be closer to last year's Panthers with a shaky D, more opportunity to air it out, and less to lose if there's a turnover here or there.

            Wilson's the wild card (no offense but I don't think the other two will be in the discussion at all) if only bc he's the one with the best shot at the playoffs AND the biggest competition behind him. He could easily lose his job, even if it's to injury. That's just not happening with RG3 or Luck.

            Comment

            • ImaGamer_OS
              Future EA Game Changer
              • Apr 2012
              • 523

              #7
              Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

              Joe Montana took Andrew Luck over RGIII for having the better career long term of First Take this morning. Not a bad endorsement.
              Last edited by ImaGamer_OS; 08-27-2012, 07:10 PM.
              Support: Indianapolis Colts - LA Lakers - Chelsea FC - Ferrari F1

              Comment

              • slickdtc
                Grayscale
                • Aug 2004
                • 17125

                #8
                Honestly, I like all of these guys coming out. I'm pretty sure Luck and RG3 are going to be pretty good. I think they'll both put up good numbers and also show off their greenness by having a good amount of INT's, too. But their teams will be excited to see them progress with their respective teams.

                Wilson and Tannehill are where it could go either way. I thought Wilson was a steal, but I just have this feeling that Flynn will be leading Seattle by season's end whether that's due to injury, performance, etc.

                So I'm going to go with Tannehill to be this year's Dalton. Quietly put together a good campaign, and keep the Dolphins around .500. Tannehill will have the most balanced season. Just solid overall play.
                NHL - Philadelphia Flyers
                NFL - Buffalo Bills
                MLB - Cincinnati Reds


                Originally posted by Money99
                And how does one levy a check that will result in only a slight concussion? Do they set their shoulder-pads to 'stun'?

                Comment

                • wwharton
                  *ll St*r
                  • Aug 2002
                  • 26949

                  #9
                  Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                  Originally posted by ImaGamer_OS
                  Joe Montana too Andrew Luck over RGIII for having the better career long term of First Take this morning. Not a bad endorsement.
                  Best career, I'd probably agree.

                  Comment

                  • SPTO
                    binging
                    • Feb 2003
                    • 68046

                    #10
                    Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                    Originally posted by ImaGamer_OS
                    Joe Montana too Andrew Luck over RGIII for having the better career long term of First Take this morning. Not a bad endorsement.
                    While I agree with Montana if things go by the way of expectations but also keep in mind that he's one of the more vocal opponents of the spread offense and those type of QBs so while it's a great endorsement it's also one to be taken with a little grain of salt.
                    Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club

                    "Baseball is the most important thing that doesn't matter at all" - Robert B. Parker

                    Comment

                    • 55
                      Banned
                      • Mar 2006
                      • 20857

                      #11
                      Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                      Luck.

                      He can already make pretty much every throw and has the most poise I've seen from a rookie in ages.

                      Comment

                      • thaima1shu
                        Robot
                        • Feb 2004
                        • 5598

                        #12
                        Originally posted by 55
                        Luck.

                        He can already make pretty much every throw and has the most poise I've seen from a rookie in ages.
                        I originally voted Wilson but the more I think about it, the more I would say it should be Luck. He's pretty much incredible

                        Comment

                        • kingkilla56
                          Hall Of Fame
                          • Jun 2009
                          • 19395

                          #13
                          Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                          I think RG3 is gonna take some major lumps this season.
                          Tweet Tweet

                          Comment

                          • Aggies7
                            All Star
                            • Jan 2005
                            • 9495

                            #14
                            I think Luck and the Colts will shock some people. I really see him having the best rookie season.

                            I will say I would love to see Russell Wilson have a huge year. I really like watching him in college and hope him the best in the pros.

                            As for RGIII it will really depend on his protection. I know he can get away but they have to give him some time or he will end up with a bunch of fumble or worse an injury.

                            As for Tannehill I am not a fan of him starting. I really think he was a project and needs more time before being thrown into the fire.

                            I think when it comes to stats Andrew Luck will have the best statistical season.

                            As for team win/loss record I would say Russell Wilson.
                            Texas A&M Aggies
                            Denver Broncos

                            Colorado Avalanche
                            Colorado Rockies

                            Comment

                            • ProfessaPackMan
                              Bamma
                              • Mar 2008
                              • 63852

                              #15
                              Re: NFL | Who has the better rookie season at QB?

                              I can't answer the question until the OP defines the word "better".
                              #RespectTheCulture

                              Comment

                              Working...