[charter04]

Quote: Originally Posted by DetroitStyle

Charter, your set is the first I've thoroughly tested so I will try and provide as much feedback as possible including box scores. Here's my most recent game: Bills (user) Patriots (cpu). This was done in Play Now with speed set to VERY SLOW. Buffalo Bills at New England Patriots Jan 1, 1ST 2ND 3RD 4TH SCORE Buffalo Bills (USER) 7 7 7 7 28 New England Patriots (CPU) 3 14 3 3 23 Team Stats Comparison BUF NWE Total Offense 380 411 Rushing Yards 217 118 Passing Yards 163 293 First Downs 22 20 Punt Return Yards 24 0 Kick Return Yards 101 0 Total Yards 505 411 Turnovers 0 0 3rd Down Converstion 7-13 5-13 4th Down Conversion 1-1 0-1 2-Point Conversion 0-0 0-0 Red Zone Touchdowns/Field Goals 3-3 2-2 Penalties 6-49 18-176 Posession Time 26:07 33:53 Scoring Summary FIRST QUARTER SCORING BUF NWE 8:33 (BUF) C. Spiller, 33 Yd run 7 0 3:04 (NWE) S. Gostkowski, 48 Yd FG 7 3 SECOND QUARTER SCORING BUF NWE 7:53 (NWE) W. Welker 59 Yd pass from T. Brady 7 10 5:36 (BUF) C. Spiller, 2 Yd run 14 10 0:04 (NWE) B. Lloyd 7 Yd pass from T. Brady 14 17 THIRD QUARTER SCORING BUF NWE 8:18 (NWE) S. Gostkowski, 20 Yd FG 14 20 0:30 (BUF) S. Chandler 4 Yd pass from R. Fitzpatrick 21 20 FOURTH QUARTER SCORING BUF NWE 10:51 (NWE) S. Gostkowski, 46 Yd FG 21 23 9:08 (BUF) S. Chandler 15 Yd pass from R. Fitzpatrick 28 23 Buffalo Bills PASSING C/A YDS TD INT R. Fitzpatrick 18/33 176 2 0 RUSHING ATT YDS AVG TD F. Jackson 22 147 6.6 0 C. Spiller 8 79 9.8 2 R. Fitzpatrick 2 -4 -2.0 0 S. Johnson 1 -5 -5.0 0 RECEIVING REC YDS AVG TD D. Hagan 4 56 14.0 0 S. Johnson 4 42 10.5 0 S. Chandler 3 29 9.6 2 M. Easley 3 21 7.0 0 DEFENSE TACK SACK INT TD C. Kelsay 1 1 0 0 K. Williams 1 1 0 0 M. Williams 4 1 0 0 KICKING FG XP PTS LONG R. Lindell 0/2 2/2 4 0 New England Patriots PASSING C/A YDS TD INT T. Brady 27/33 314 2 0 RUSHING ATT YDS AVG TD S. Ridley 25 96 3.8 0 D. Woodhead 2 19 9.5 0 W. Welker 1 3 3.0 0 RECEIVING REC YDS AVG TD W. Welker 13 191 14.6 1 R. Gronkowski 3 11 3.6 0 A. Hernandez 3 36 12.0 0 D. Branch 3 37 12.3 0 S. Ridley 3 28 9.3 0 DEFENSE TACK SACK INT TD V. Wilfork 2 1 0 0 C. Jones 4 1 0 0 KICKING FG XP PTS LONG S. Gostkowski 3/3 2/2 11 49 Gameplay: - Number of plays looks good. You want between 120-140 combined and this on 15 minute quarters works great. - CPU Rushing attack and passing attack can be dangerous, especially against lesser defenses. Might even have to improve User rush defense and crank User pass defense to 100. - User running game is no challenge at all. Everyone will have to tweak this to their liking but as you can see it was no issue at all for me. - I like the amount of broken tackles. It seems perfect so the CPU can actually break a few big gains. - I didn't see any turnovers so you might want to up fumbles back to 50 or 40. I'd be careful toying with the interception slider as it seems to be a pick fest this year. I tested this game with interceptions at 20 for both teams. Special Teams: - I like what others have said about punt accuracy. You might want it at 75-100 for both to keep games interesting. The CPU can't locate punts well at the current setting. - Lindell missed two 50+ yard field goals. He came up a few yards short on both with max power. He has a 89 kick power rating. Gastkowski on the other hand had no problem with distance as he knocked two 40+ yarders with a 92 kick power rating. 45 may be perfect but also may need to be brought up to 50. - I've test accuracy numerous times in practice and 30-35 seems to give the appropriate amount of misses Penalties: - I set all penalties to 100 to get the ball rolling on finding perfect settings. With all set to 100 there were 24 penalties total. Here's the breakdown: 10 Holding, 7 Face Masks, 1 Roughing the Passer, 5 False Start. - Note that there were ZERO interference calls, as usual, and that there were no clipping calls, which is usually the #1 penalty called in EA football games. Not so at 100. Also there were no offsides even though the line did a jump-the-snap animation all the time. Kind of weird... - What's also interesting is how skewed the penalties were to the CPU. Just bad luck? Possibly... - You want to average between 4-10 penalties a game, with some games higher or lower. With False Start at 100 the penalties between offense and defense should balance out. Here's my reccommend settings for now: Holding - 55 Facemask - 65 Everything else at 100 Intangibles: - Stamina seems perfect for now at 60. It's hard to live with this setting since auto subs are broken but we'll deal with it. - Injuries need to be set at 25. At 50 I would see between 5-7 injuries a game. At 25 you see between 1-3. This most recent game had 2. Still testing though. PHEW! Sorry for the long winded post, but I hope the feedback helps!!!!

Awesome feedback! This is the type of detail I am wanting. I am glad someone tested the penalties because I didn't want to. LOL. Love the injury feedback as well. I will probably plug these in and go with them. Also the human run game seems to be the speed of game your playing. Very Slow makes it easier to run than normal in my experience because you have more time to react. You might just need to lower the run blocking. SECelite told me that he went as far as about 5 -10 on human run blocking and they were still pulling and overall blocking correctly. I wouldn't go that far but you could lower it some until it gives you the right challenge. Also the fumble sliders works were lower gives you more fumbles so you might want to lower the CPU and User fumble slider. Be careful lower the user one though. I guy a few posted up had 4 in a game. I don't think he was covering the ball though.

Overall your feed back it great. I am really glad these work with very slow. Keep the feedback coming it's very helpful.