Who are your WRs? The catching at 45 forces you to pay attention to your personnel and there attributes. You can't expect some low rated guys to hold on to everything. Out of all the games I tested so far I haven't had no where near that amount of drops per game.. Maybe like 2 to 3 with a few games where I had like 4 or 5 but nothing out of the ordinary.. I don't know what to tell you to do because I like the catching at 45. It's been perfect for me but I am using the Giants.. You can maybe raise the USER catching to 46 or 47 and see if that works for you. Just make sure you don't take that USER category over 75.. Which set are you using BTW?