I get the feelings ratings dont always work

[chargerrich]

Playing offline franchise.

Antonio Gates catches a little slant at my own 35 against the Falcons and proceeds to go HOUSE is a straight line untouched with 3 Falcon DBs on his hips at the 50... ALL with more speed and they simply cannot close the 2 yard gap, in 50 yards. Really?

I have the player speed threshold set at 20 which I "thought" made speed differences between players more relevant. Should this setting be higher? I was pretty sure in M12 that the lower the more of a gap was created.

Gates is a great TE, but he should NEVER go 65 yards... :P

[JaymeeAwesome]

I have mine set at 11, but noticed many members playing with it at 0

[Gritblitzer]

Re: I get the feelings ratings dont always work

I'm starting to believe Madden just hates the Falcons. I can play with the Oakland Raiders and blow people out. I play with the Falcons and it's like all my players drop wide open passes, fumble the ball, and are simply slow. Then again, it could just be me.

[jwhite1347]

Re: I get the feelings ratings dont always work

Dude tell me about it. I switched all my lineman to zero ratings and saw no difference. In fact on sim they seemed to do better.

[californ14]

Re: I get the feelings ratings dont always work

Fatigue? Player traits taking effect? Other attributes coming into play? If it was just all about speed, then DB's should run down a TE, generally speaking, but I believe there is more to it....Antonio Gates is an All-Pro player....

[californ14]

Re: I get the feelings ratings dont always work

Dude tell me about it. I switched all my lineman to zero ratings and saw no difference. In fact on sim they seemed to do better.

I have done tests on this because people have shown videos of QB's, K's and P's blocking ALL-Pro defensive linemen and the Defense always gets through; the defense gets better as you raise the difficulty....

[Carlboy82]

Re: I get the feelings ratings dont always work

It's all in the difficulty, and slider settings. I took the Bears defense, and lowered all the starting lineup players to zero on tackle rating, and hit power rating. It had NO effect whatsoever on the tackling. Not until I messed with the sliders, particularly Break Tackle, and Tackle sliders, did i see a difference. I believe this game has always been this way. I watched a replay of a play where the TE caught a pass, and then ran for 48 yds with two DB's giving chase, and neither one could close the 2 yd gap for the 48 yd run after the catch. The TE had a speed rating of 86, and the DB's were speed rated at 89, and 90. Threshold was at 8. The two yard gap never changed. Total BS as far as I'm concerned. This game needs to stop being touted as SIM football, because it's not!

[californ14]

Re: I get the feelings ratings dont always work

I believe the difference between an 86 spd and a 90 spd is in the 100ths of a sec....So other attributes could be playing a role and actually reducing the DB's ratings or even increasing the ratings of the TE possibly....

[xzayla]

Re: I get the feelings ratings dont always work

I switched all my lineman to zero ratings and saw no difference.

What level are you playing on?

I did this and noticed a difference for sure. Not huge but definitely noticable.

[Old School SD Fan]

Re: I get the feelings ratings dont always work

Ratings in this game like many penalties are just there to make you THINK they do something. Seen a clipping call this year? I haven't.

Biggest gameplay issue is in games played 90% of the ratings don't matter. Speed is one that does, surprised to hear your story.